Axis study gallery

Every set participants made while trying the axis-diversity tool. Each person typed a prompt, saw what the model made on its own, then named what should vary across the pictures — the axis, quoted exactly as they wrote it. Participants are shown as numbers, not names.

Updated Sep 27, 2026 06:32

Participant 1 · Sep 25, 04:39

a sculptor puts the finishing touches on a state of a piece of sporting equipment

Prompt changed

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1

different sporting equipment, sculptor appearance, composition, color palette, facial hair, tool being used

13 words

new set · diversity 0.56

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A sculptor puts the finishing touches on a state of a piece of sporting equipment: a tennis racquet. Elderly male sculptor with white beard, detailed welding torch, studio lighting, warm amber color palette, focused expression.

2A sculptor puts the finishing touches on a state of a piece of sporting equipment: sleek swimming goggles. Young female sculptor with short bob hair, using fine sanding brush, close-up face, cool blue and silver color palette.

3A sculptor puts the finishing touches on a state of a piece of sporting equipment: ornate racing helmet. Handsome male sculptor with thick mustache, using polishing cloth, dynamic side profile composition, vibrant red and gold tones.

4A sculptor puts the finishing touches on a state of a piece of sporting equipment: futuristic skateboard. Diverse female sculptor with braided hair, using power drill, wide angle composition, neon purple and electric blue color palette.

Round 2

different sporting equipment, sculptor appearance, composition, color palette, facial hair, tool being used

13 words

new set · diversity 0.22

round 2 image 1round 2 image 2round 2 image 3round 2 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1a sculptor puts the finishing touches on a state of a piece of cycling gear, diverse background, vibrant color palette, clean-shaven sculptor, using a chisel

2a sculptor puts the finishing touches on a state of a piece of boxing equipment, elderly sculptor with white beard, dark composition, cool blue palette, using a fine file

3a sculptor puts the finishing touches on a state of a piece of fishing gear, young sculptor with short hair, side profile composition, warm orange palette, using a steel scraper

4a sculptor puts the finishing touches on a state of a piece of swimming equipment, woman sculptor with long hair, centered composition, neutral gray palette, using a bonding brush

Participant 1 · Sep 25, 04:46

a sculptor puts the finishing touches on a statue of a piece of sporting equipment

Prompt changed

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis. The participant revised the prompt; it was: “a sculptor puts the finishing touches on a state of a piece of sporting equipment”.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1

different sporting equipment, sculptor appearance, composition, color palette, facial hair, tool being used

13 words

new set · diversity 0.56

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A sculptor puts the finishing touches on a statue of a piece of sporting equipment: a statue of a tennis racquet. Old sculptor with white beard, traditional tools, warm golden hour lighting, detailed marble texture.

2A sculptor puts the finishing touches on a statue of a piece of sporting equipment: a statue of a running shoe. Young female sculptor with short hair, electric blue and neon orange color palette, dramatic shadows, modern workshop.

3A sculptor puts the finishing touches on a statue of a piece of sporting equipment: a statue of a basketball. Male sculptor with goatee, using wire brushes and chisels, dynamic diagonal composition, vibrant red and green palette.

4A sculptor puts the finishing touches on a statue of a piece of sporting equipment: a statue of a golf club. Female sculptor with dark braids, using sculpting hammer, close-up composition, monochrome black and white style.

Round 2

different sporting equipment, sculptor appearance, composition, color palette, facial hair, tool being used

13 words

new set · diversity 0.33

round 2 image 1round 2 image 2round 2 image 3round 2 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A sculptor puts finishing touches on a statue of a soccer ball. An elderly Asian sculptor with a long white beard uses a fine brush. Warm golden hour lighting, close-up composition.

2A sculptor puts finishing touches on a statue of a racing bicycle. A muscular young male sculptor with intricate tattoos uses a sharp chisel. Cool blue and silver color palette, low angle wide shot.

3A sculptor puts finishing touches on a statue of a boxing glove. A female sculptor with short dark hair uses a soft cloth. Vibrant red and green color palette, macro detail on the sculptor's hands.

4A sculptor puts finishing touches on a statue of a tennis racket. An older male sculptor with a mustache uses a polishing wheel. Dramatic shadowed composition, warm amber and dark brown tones.

Participant 1 · Sep 25, 04:47

a sculptor puts the finishing touches on a large statue of a piece of sporting equipment

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis. The participant revised the prompt; it was: “a sculptor puts the finishing touches on a statue of a piece of sporting equipment”.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1

different sporting equipment, sculptor appearance, composition, color palette, facial hair, tool being used

13 words

new set · diversity 0.44

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A sculptor puts finishing touches on a large statue of a football helmet. Elderly bearded man with wild hair, using a small chisel, dramatic side lighting, warm earth tones.

2A sculptor puts finishing touches on a large statue of a tennis racket. Young stylish woman with short blonde hair, using a polishing cloth, bright sunny park background, vibrant blue and green palette.

3A sculptor puts finishing touches on a large statue of a Olympic swimming cap. Muscular male sculptor with a clean buzzcut and mustache, using a fine sandblaster, high-angle shot, cool metallic silver and white colors.

4A sculptor puts finishing touches on a large statue of a baseball glove. Diverse group of two sculptors working together, one wearing glasses holding a hammer, dynamic low angle, rich crimson and gold color scheme.

Round 2 Accepted

different sporting equipment, sculptor appearance, composition, color palette, facial hair, tool being used

13 words

new set · diversity 0.11

varied ★★★☆☆ matched ★★☆☆☆

“Three of the four images still retain the composition of the sculptor on the left side of the image. Two of the four have beards, and images 2 and 4 have similar palettes. Among the most significant issues is that images 1, 3, and arguably 2 no longer adhere to the prompt, as the object being worked on by the sculptor does not resemble anything that could be reasonably sculpted.”

round 2 image 1round 2 image 2round 2 image 3round 2 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1a sculptor puts the finishing touches on a large statue of a golf club, an elderly sculptor with a long white beard, low angle shot, black and white composition, using a chisel.

2a sculptor puts the finishing touches on a large statue of a tennis racket, a female sculptor with short hair, wide angle view, vibrant neon color palette, using a welding torch.

3a sculptor puts the finishing touches on a large statue of a boxing glove, a rotund sculptor with a goatee, split composition, warm golden hour lighting, using a paintbrush.

4a sculptor puts the finishing touches on a large statue of a basketball, a young male sculptor clean shaven, symmetrical composition, cool blue and grey palette, using a fine sculpting knife.

Participant 1 · Sep 25, 04:51

a person sitting at a desk daydreams about their upcoming vacation

Prompt changed

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Participant 1 · Sep 25, 04:53

a person sits at a desk and daydreams about their upcoming vacation, in visible thought bubble

Prompt changed

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis. The participant revised the prompt; it was: “a person sitting at a desk daydreams about their upcoming vacation”.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Participant 1 · Sep 25, 04:54

a person stands on the deck of their beach house watching a massive creature in the distance

Prompt changed

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis. The participant revised the prompt; it was: “a person sits at a desk and daydreams about their upcoming vacation, in visible thought bubble”.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Participant 1 · Sep 25, 04:55

a person sits at a desk and daydreams about their upcoming vacation, in visible thought bubble

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis. The participant revised the prompt; it was: “a person stands on the deck of their beach house watching a massive creature in the distance”.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Accepted

composition, framing, facial hair, hair color, desk, office, vacation setting, thought bubble design

13 words

new set · diversity 0.44

varied ★★★☆☆ matched ★★★★☆

“The reimagined images are most successful in achieving new composition and framing, though the note about "facial hair" was interpreted as a request for a variety in facial hair, which is an admittedly reasonable interpretation. Three out of four images still employ a beach setting as the vacation destination, and the thought bubbles vary, but only in subtle ways. The loss in gender diversity is unfortunate, though gender was not mentioned within the prompt. This set of images is, on the whole, more effective than the initial batch.”

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1a person sits at a desk and daydreams about their upcoming vacation, in visible thought bubble. Wide shot composition, full body framing, wearing a suit, clean shaved face, brown hair, simple white desk, modern glass office.

2a person sits at a desk and daydreams about their upcoming vacation, in visible thought bubble. Close-up face composition, tight framing on head, long beard, blonde hair, cluttered wooden desk, cozy library office, cloud-shaped bubble.

3a person sits at a desk and daydreams about their upcoming vacation, in visible thought bubble. Top-down composition, high angle framing, no facial hair, red hair, sleek metal desk, café workspace, tropical beach scene bubble.

4a person sits at a desk and daydreams about their upcoming vacation, in visible thought bubble. Side profile composition, Dutch angle framing, thick mustache, grey hair, shared community desk, vibrant city office, illustrated map bubble.

Participant 1 · Sep 25, 05:00

a person stands on the deck of their beach house, watching a massive creature approaching in the distance

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Accepted

creature design, person's age, person's gender, angle, deck design, time of day

12 words

new set · diversity 0.33

varied ★★★★☆ matched ★★★★★

“The creatures are now sufficiently varied across generations, and every individual viewing the creature is demographically distinct. Two daytime shots, an early evening shot, and a nighttime shot represent sufficient diversity in time of day, and each image contains a unique deck design, as well as somewhat different framing/composition. This batch was very successful overall.”

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A person stands on the deck of their beach house, watching a massive kraken approaching in the distance. The person is a young boy. High angle shot.

2A person stands on the deck of their beach house, watching a massive dragon approaching in the distance. The person is an elderly woman. Low ground angle.

3A person stands on the deck of their beach house, watching a massive alien monster approaching in the distance. The person is a middle-aged man. Sunset time.

4A person stands on the deck of their beach house, watching a colossal sea serpent approaching in the distance. The person is a young woman. Night time.

Participant 2 · Sep 25, 05:02

a tiny floating library above a rainy city at dusk

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Accepted

architectural style

2 words

new set · diversity 0.67

varied ★★★★★ matched ★★★★★

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1a tiny floating library above a rainy city at dusk, ancient Greek temple architecture, stone columns, marble shelves, glowing lanterns, moody atmosphere

2a tiny floating library above a rainy city at dusk, futuristic cyberpunk design, neon lights, holographic books, glass towers, chaotic rain, dusk sky

3a tiny floating library above a rainy city at dusk, organic biophilic style, lush vines, wooden beams, moss-covered books, cozy windows, rainy dusk

4a tiny floating library above a rainy city at dusk, brutalist concrete structure, geometric shapes, stark white walls, industrial pipes, dramatic lighting, dusk rain

Participant 3 · Sep 25, 05:03

an eagle siting in the frame of a glass window or a wooden house during fall season

Stopped before choosing an axis

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Participant 1 · Sep 25, 05:04

an alien and robot shake hands in front of a famous landmark

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Accepted

alien design, robot design, landmark, angle, time of day

9 words

new set · diversity 0.56

varied ★★★☆☆ matched ★★★★★

“Each image features a distinct landmark, and a sufficient variety in the time of day is also present. The designs of the aliens in images 1, 3, and 4 are subtly different, while 2 pleasingly includes an entirely original design. Similarly, the robots in 1, 3, and 4 are subtly different, with 2's being wholly original. While a greater degree of variety in these designs would be preferred, this is a successful batch of images overall.”

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1An alien and robot shake hands in front of the Eiffel Tower. The alien has three green eyes and large antennae. The robot is silver with gears. Daylight, front view.

2An alien and robot shake hands in front of the Great Pyramid of Giza. The alien is tiny, purple, and fluffy. The robot is rusty and heavy. Sunset background, low angle.

3An alien and robot shake hands in front of the Statue of Liberty. The alien is tall, slender, and blue skin. The robot is sleek, black, and humanoid. Nighttime with city lights.

4An alien and robot shake hands in front of Machu Picchu. The alien looks like a classic insectoid with exoskeleton. The robot has a glowing core. Morning mist, side profile angle.

Participant 2 · Sep 25, 05:07

a night market on a floating island above the ocean

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Accepted

lighting and time of day

5 words

new set · diversity 0.67

varied ★★★★★ matched ★★★★★

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1a night market on a floating island above the ocean. Deep night, dark blue sky, bioluminescent glowing signs, lanterns, neon lights, stars, moon, magical atmosphere.

2a night market on a floating island above the ocean. Dawn breaking, soft pink and orange sky, sun rising behind clouds, fresh morning light hitting the stalls, vendors waking up.

3a night market on a floating island above the ocean. Midnight, full supermoon casting silver light, dramatic storm clouds, heavy shadows, intense orange and purple lightning illuminating vibrant stalls.

4a night market on a floating island above the ocean. Evening twilight, golden hour transitioning to night, warm amber lanterns glowing brightly, fireworks exploding in the dark sky above the water.

Participant 3 · Sep 25, 05:07

two boys aged around 10 playing in park

Prompt changed

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Participant 3 · Sep 25, 05:11

two boys aged around 10 playing in park, a ball

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis. The participant revised the prompt; it was: “two boys aged around 10 playing in park”.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Accepted

Include a ball

3 words

new set · diversity 0.11

varied ★★★★☆ matched ★★★★☆

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1two boys aged around 10 playing in park, a red ball

2two boys aged around 10 playing in park, a blue ball

3two boys aged around 10 playing in park, a soccer ball

4two boys aged around 10 playing in park, a basketball

Participant 2 · Sep 25, 05:08

a red panda explorer in a desert observatory

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Accepted

season of the year

4 words

new set · diversity 0.67

varied ★★★★★ matched ★★★★★

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1a red panda explorer in a desert observatory, snowy winter season, snow-covered dunes, aurora borealis sky, warm observatory lights, exploring winter gear, cold atmospheric.

2a red panda explorer in a desert observatory, vibrant spring season, blooming desert flowers, colorful butterfly, sunny blue sky, green cacti, spring breeze, exploration.

3a red panda explorer in a desert observatory, lush summer season, hot sun, palm trees in oasis, starry night sky, telescope ready, cool evening attire.

4a red panda explorer in a desert observatory, crisp autumn season, orange maple leaves falling, golden hour sunlight, warm scarf, stargazing, fall colors.

Participant 1 · Sep 25, 05:08

a well-dressed ape puts the finishing touches on a masterwork painting

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Accepted

attire, subject of painting, painting frame, color palette, composition, type of ape

12 words

new set · diversity 0.33

varied ★★★☆☆ matched ★★★☆☆

“Three of the four images retain the composition of the ape being on the left side of the image. The ape in the second image appears slightly distinct from the rest, though they are overall fairly similar. The design of the frame varies across each completion, as does the subject of the painting. The attire is fairly diverse, though the sailor outfit arguably lies outside of the realm of being "well-dressed," and the ape in the fourth image is not putting the finishing touches on the painting. These issues detract from an otherwise satisfactory batch of images.”

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A well-dressed ape puts finishing touches on masterwork painting; ape wears a tuxedo, painting depicts a moon, ornate gold frame, cool blue palette, close-up composition, chimpanzee type.

2A well-dressed ape puts finishing touches on masterwork painting; ape wears a sailor outfit, painting depicts a pirate ship, dark wood frame, fiery orange palette, wide angle composition, gorilla type.

3A well-dressed ape puts finishing touches on masterwork painting; ape wears a regal robe, painting depicts a dragon, crystal frame, vibrant green palette, dynamic swirling composition, orangutan type.

4A well-dressed ape puts finishing touches on masterwork painting; ape wears formal business suit, painting depicts a cityscape, minimalist silver frame, monochrome grey palette, symmetrical center composition, baboon type.

Their questionnaire

Slider behaved as expected: ★★★★☆

Enjoyed the task: ★★★★★

Preferred: Generate new

Uses image generators: Weekly or more

Wanted to vary but could not: It may be useful to have some sort of toggle/slider that influences the framing/ composition of the image, as it is something that frequently would benefit from additional diversity, and it can become tricky to request when the content of the prompt features "composition" or "framing" as part of their vocabulary (such as in the last set with the painting).

Other: Nothing at this time.

Would do more: Yes

Useful to say what varies: ★★★★☆

Participant 2 · Sep 25, 05:10

a vintage train crossing a snowy mountain bridge

Stopped before choosing an axis

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Participant 2 · Sep 25, 05:13

a vintage train crossing a snowy mountain bridge

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Accepted

weather conditions

2 words

new set · diversity 0.11

varied ★★★★★ matched ★★★★★

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1a vintage train crossing a snowy mountain bridge, blizzard weather conditions

2a vintage train crossing a snowy mountain bridge, foggy weather conditions

3a vintage train crossing a snowy mountain bridge, sunny weather conditions

4a vintage train crossing a snowy mountain bridge, rainy weather conditions

Participant 2 · Sep 25, 05:14

a coral reef research station beneath Antarctic ice

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Accepted

type of marine life

4 words

new set · diversity 0.11

varied ★★★★★ matched ★★★★★

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1a coral reef research station beneath Antarctic ice with vibrant jellyfish thriving

2a coral reef research station beneath Antarctic ice with curious Emperor penguins diving

3a coral reef research station beneath Antarctic ice surrounded by colossal whale sharks

4a coral reef research station beneath Antarctic ice hosting deep-sea sponges glowing

Their questionnaire

Useful to say what varies: ★★★★★

Slider behaved as expected: ★★★★★

Preferred: Generate new

Uses image generators: A few times

Wanted to vary but could not: The tool handled the requested variation axes well.

Would do more: Maybe

Enjoyed the task: ★★★★★

Participant 3 · Sep 25, 05:16

A racing blue sports motorbike parked on the side of a highway with no rider in vicinity

Not what they wanted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Rejected

No clear signs of a highway

6 words

new set · diversity 0.44

varied ★★☆☆☆ matched ★★☆☆☆

“Just one included a highway”

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A racing blue sports motorbike parked on the side of a dirt road with no rider in vicinity, clear sky and dry grass.

2A racing blue sports motorbike parked on the edge of a quiet country lane with no rider in vicinity, lush greenery around.

3A racing blue sports motorbike parked in an empty urban parking garage with no rider in vicinity, concrete walls visible.

4A racing blue sports motorbike parked on a scenic forest path with no rider in vicinity, trees framing the scene closely.

Participant 3 · Sep 25, 05:28

A teacher in class

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Accepted

The phots generated are students and not teaahcer

8 words

new set · diversity 1.00

varied ★★★★★ matched ★★★★☆

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A teacher in class. Focus on the teacher: a friendly female professor standing at a blackboard, pointing, wearing glasses, formal dress, smiling, students blurred in background listening.

2A teacher in class. A diverse group of students sitting at desks, taking notes, raising hands, happy faces, colorful uniforms, books, backpacks, teacher visible in background supervising.

3A teacher in class. Close up on students: group of young boys and girls studying together, laughing, discussing, art supplies, maps on wall, teacher watching from side doorway.

4A teacher in class. Students playing sports inside classroom, energetic kids running, jumping, uniforms, coach/teacher giving instructions, balls, banners, vibrant colors, fun atmosphere.

Participant 3 · Sep 25, 05:32

A coffee plantation during fall

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1

Clearly show ripe coffee berries but keep the 'fall' tree background

11 words

new set · diversity 0.56

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A coffee plantation during fall. Clearly show many ripe red coffee berries on bushes, with vibrant orange and yellow autumn leaves in the background trees.

2A coffee plantation during fall. Close-up of ripe dark purple coffee berries, golden fall foliage and brown trunks in the blurred background.

3A coffee plantation during fall. Rows of coffee plants heavy with bright red ripe berries, surrounded by majestic trees with falling green and orange leaves.

4A coffee plantation during fall. Macro shot of ripe yellow coffee berries on branches, dramatic backlight through colorful fall forest canopy in distance.

Round 2 Accepted

Clearly show ripe coffee berries but keep the 'fall' tree background

11 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.56

varied ★★★☆☆ matched ★★★☆☆

“Only the second and the fourth are right”

round 2 image 1round 2 image 2round 2 image 3round 2 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1(kept as it was)

2Make the ripe coffee berries translucent with water droplets shining on them.

3(kept as it was)

4Change the berries to ripening greenish-yellow coffee cherries in the foreground.

Participant 3 · Sep 25, 05:37

executive office setup

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Accepted

change to executive office not shared workstation

7 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.78

varied ★☆☆☆☆ matched ★☆☆☆☆

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1(kept as it was)

2(kept as it was)

3(kept as it was)

4Add a glass partition wall and meeting area behind the desk

Their questionnaire

Useful to say what varies: ★★★★★

Slider behaved as expected: ★★★☆☆

Enjoyed the task: ★★★★★

Preferred: Both, for different things

Uses image generators: A few times

Wanted to vary but could not: yes. Changing office set up

Would do more: Yes

Participant 4 · Sep 25, 07:38

several covers for a modern videogames magazine

Prompt changed

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Participant 4 · Sep 25, 07:40

cover for a modern videogames magazine

Prompt changed

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis. The participant revised the prompt; it was: “several covers for a modern videogames magazine”.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1

more variation in the font style and colour

8 words

new set · diversity 0.44

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1cover for a modern videogames magazine, bold 3D metallic silver typography, dynamic action scene, vibrant colors

2cover for a modern videogames magazine, elegant thin white serif font, sleek minimalist design, futuristic gaming landscapes

3cover for a modern videogames magazine, chaotic graffiti-style splattered neon font, gritty urban gaming poster, high contrast

4cover for a modern videogames magazine, playful rounded pastel bubbly letters, colorful cartoonish game art, bright cheerful style

Participant 4 · Sep 25, 07:43

cover for a modern videogames magazine, all English language

Not what they wanted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis. The participant revised the prompt; it was: “cover for a modern videogames magazine”.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1

more variation in the font style and colour

8 words

new set · diversity 0.11

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1cover for a modern videogames magazine, all English language, bold neon red futuristic font

2cover for a modern videogames magazine, all English language, elegant thin serif gold font

3cover for a modern videogames magazine, all English language, chunky black blocky font with 3D effect

4cover for a modern videogames magazine, all English language, handwritten gradient rainbow font

Round 2

more variation in the font style and colour

8 words

new set · diversity 0.11

round 2 image 1round 2 image 2round 2 image 3round 2 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1cover for a modern videogames magazine, all English language, bold black sans-serif title font

2cover for a modern videogames magazine, all English language, vibrant neon green handwritten title font

3cover for a modern videogames magazine, all English language, sleek metallic silver futuristic title font

4cover for a modern videogames magazine, all English language, classic deep red serif title font

Round 3 Rejected

more variation in the font style and colour

8 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.11

varied ★☆☆☆☆ matched ★★★☆☆

“They vary but they don't look like videogames magazines :/”

round 3 image 1round 3 image 2round 3 image 3round 3 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1Change the font to a condensed, minimalist sans-serif and color the title bold white.

2Change the font to a jagged, handwritten style and color it vibrant neon pink.

3Change the font to a wide, artistic brush script and color it electric blue.

4Change the font to a thin, geometric sans-serif and color the text deep gold.

Participant 4 · Sep 25, 07:45

a group of students having a picnic in a park setting

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Accepted

more variety in angle of picture

6 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.22

varied ★★★★☆ matched ★★★★★

“It made the variations correctly, except in the 3rd picture you can't see that it's a picnic specifically.”

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1change the camera view to a wide high-angle shot looking down at the group.

2change the camera view to a low-angle shot looking up at the group from the grass.

3change the camera view to a close-up shot focusing on the faces of two students.

4change the camera view to a side profile shot capturing the group in a horizontal line.

Participant 4 · Sep 25, 07:47

a man and his dog walking over Yorkshire moors

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1

different breeds of dog and different clothes on owner

9 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.44

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1change the dog breed to a Golden Retriever and the man's clothes to a red windbreaker and orange trousers

2change the dog breed to a Doberman Pinscher and the man's clothes to a beige shirt and khaki shorts

3change the dog breed to a Labrador Retriever and the man's clothes to a floral dress and sun hat

4change the dog breed to an Afghan Hound and the man's clothes to a tactical vest and camouflage trousers

Round 2 Accepted

different breeds of dog and different clothes on owner

9 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.33

varied ★★★★★ matched ★★★★★

“Variation worked, but the pictures look really artificial”

round 2 image 1round 2 image 2round 2 image 3round 2 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1Change the dog breed to a beagle and add a blue denim jacket with a knit hat to the man

2Change the dog breed to a Rough Collie and add a white button-down shirt and beige linen trousers to the man

3Keep the dog breed as a Labrador Retriever, but change the man's clothes to a full floral print dress and a wide-brimmed straw hat

4Change the dog breed to a German Shepherd and add a military-style camouflage uniform and tactical vest to the man

Participant 4 · Sep 25, 07:50

a tropical bird sat on a branch

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Accepted

the background of the photo

5 words

new set · diversity 0.56

varied ★★★★★ matched ★★★★★

“That worked really well, it really mixed up what I asked for, all completely different :)”

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1a tropical bird sat on a branch, close-up portrait, plain white background, soft lighting

2a tropical bird sat on a branch, lush green rainforest jungle background, dense foliage, sunlight filtering through leaves

3a tropical bird sat on a branch, dramatic sunset ocean background, pink and orange sky, waves crashing below

4a tropical bird sat on a branch, futuristic neon city skyline background at night, vibrant lights, cyberpunk style

Participant 4 · Sep 25, 07:52

t shirt design for a death metal band

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1

style of picture on front

5 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.78

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1add a vibrant retro wave sunset background behind the skull and text

2change the image style to a realistic photograph of a vintage t-shirt hanging on a rack with people in the background

3add a detailed, hand-drawn illustration of a fantasy landscape with a castle behind the skull

4add a futuristic cyberpunk cityscape background with neon lights behind the design

Round 2 Accepted

colour and font of band name

6 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.44

varied ★★★★☆ matched ★★★★★

“The last variations did as asked, and made all 4 look more distinct from each other, while still fitting the brief”

round 2 image 1round 2 image 2round 2 image 3round 2 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1change the band name text to "CHASM" in bright neon blue with a blocky modern font

2change the band name text to "TORMENT" in yellow metallic with a jagged gothic font

3change the band name text to "WITHER" in white with a clean sans-serif font and add a rainbow gradient behind the letters

4change the band name text to "VOID" in silver chrome with a double-stroke outline and typewriter font

Their questionnaire

Useful to say what varies: ★★★★★

Slider behaved as expected: ★★★★☆

Enjoyed the task: ★★★★★

Preferred: Both, for different things

Uses image generators: A few times

Wanted to vary but could not: In the first set it would not vary the designs in the way I wanted, and the magazine covers looked almost like men's style magazines rather than game magazines in some instances

Other: This was really fun. I'd definitely use such a tool at a reasonable asking price.

Would do more: Yes

Participant 5 · Sep 25, 08:13

an old man playing another old man in chess at a public park

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Accepted

persons, park, chess pieces

4 words

new set · diversity 0.44

varied ★★★★☆ matched ★★★★★

“The image generator was right on with following the prompt. When adding pieces to differ, I feel like it could've done a better job at making the elderly men look more different from each other.”

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1an old man playing another old man in chess at a public park, diverse elderly men with different skin tones playing chess at a public park.

2an old man playing another old man in chess at a public park, the same old men intensely focusing on unique, colorful wooden chess pieces at a public park.

3an old man playing another old man in chess at a public park, old men in snow a winter public park, bare wooden chess set.

4an old man playing another old man in chess at a public park, old men surrounded by many different styles of metallic chess pieces at a public park.

Participant 6 · Sep 25, 08:20

friends playing a game in a park

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1

the number of friends, the type of game being played, the time of day

14 words

new set · diversity 0.67

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1friends playing a game in a park. Two close friends laughing while playing catch with a baseball, sunny morning, green grass, blue sky, slow motion action shot.

2friends playing a game in a park. A large group of diverse friends playing soccer, vibrant field, late afternoon golden hour, crowd cheering, dynamic sports action.

3friends playing a game in a park. Three friends intensely playing chess on a portable board, cozy evening setting, string lights, night sky, stars visible, relaxed atmosphere.

4friends playing a game in a park. Four friends playing frisbee, lively sunny noon, bright colors, laughter, trees, park benches, clear blue sky, summer vibes.

Round 2

the number of friends, the type of game being played, the time of day

14 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.56

round 2 image 1round 2 image 2round 2 image 3round 2 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1(kept as it was)

2add a soccer ball and have the 2 friends play a casual soccer match with about 10 other people in the background.

3(kept as it was)

4(kept as it was)

Round 3

the number of friends, the type of game being played, the time of day

14 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.22

round 3 image 1round 3 image 2round 3 image 3round 3 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1add a large crowd of friends and change the game to a soccer match

2(kept as it was)

3(kept as it was)

4add one girl and boy, change the game to catch flying discs, and set the time to midday

Round 5

the number of friends, the type of game being played, the time of day

14 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.67

round 5 image 1round 5 image 2round 5 image 3round 5 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1(kept as it was)

2(kept as it was)

3(kept as it was)

4Add three more friends and have them play an ultimate frisbee match.

Round 6 Accepted

the number of friends, the type of game being played, the time of day

14 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.67

varied ★★★★★ matched ★★★★★

round 6 image 1round 6 image 2round 6 image 3round 6 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1(kept as it was)

2(kept as it was)

3change the game they are playing to a card game, and set the time to evening with street lamps and stars in the background

4(kept as it was)

Participant 5 · Sep 25, 08:23

an alien walking around in a busy mall

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Accepted

alien, mall

2 words

new set · diversity 0.78

varied ★★★★★ matched ★★★★★

“I think that the machine did exactly what I asked; even after adding alterations.”

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1an alien walking around in a busy mall. The alien is small, green, with big eyes, wearing a red hoodie, holding a shopping bag, surrounded by shoppers.

2an alien walking around in a busy mall. The alien is huge, muscular, with purple skin and horns, wearing futuristic armor, walking confidently through crowded stores.

3an alien walking around in a busy mall. The alien is cute, baby-like, with multiple arms and antennae, wearing a yellow raincoat, looking at shop windows.

4an alien walking around in a busy mall. The alien is elegant, humanoid, with silver skin and flowing robes, holding a glowing staff, people admiring it.

Participant 7 · Sep 25, 08:26

Workers picking fruit

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Accepted

Change it to be a different type of fruit in each image

12 words

new set · diversity 0.11

varied ★★★★★ matched ★★★★★

“Yes, these images are all of workers picking fruit, and the fruit is different in each image.”

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1Workers picking apples

2Workers picking oranges

3Workers picking bananas

4Workers picking grapes

Participant 6 · Sep 25, 08:32

cars racing down an empty road

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1

the width of the road, the number of cars, the year/model of cars, the time of day, the location/scenery

19 words

new set · diversity 0.11

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1cars racing down a narrow dirt road during sunset in an empty desert.

2cars racing down a wide highway at midnight in an empty city tunnel.

3cars racing down a street in 1950s America with classic cars at dusk.

4cars racing down a mountain pass in 2025 with modern sports cars at dawn.

Round 2

the width of the road, the number of cars, the year/model of cars, the time of day, the location/scenery

19 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.67

round 2 image 1round 2 image 2round 2 image 3round 2 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1(kept as it was)

2change the car to a classic 1970s muscle car and widen the road to a four-lane highway with city buildings at sunset

3narrow the road to a single-lane country path through a forest and add fog at sunset

4change the car to a modern Formula 1 style car and add green race cars behind it on a track with mountains in the background

Round 3

the width of the road, the number of cars, the year/model of cars, the time of day, the location/scenery

19 words

edited the previous set · diversity 1.00

round 3 image 1round 3 image 2round 3 image 3round 3 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1(kept as it was)

2cars racing down an empty road, add a vintage 1960s muscle car in the foreground, set the time to sunset with a desert landscape background

3cars racing down an empty road, add a narrow rural dirt road lined with trees and a sunrise in the background, add one small classic car

4(kept as it was)

Round 5

the width of the road, the number of cars, the year/model of cars, the time of day, the location/scenery

19 words

edited the previous set · diversity 1.00

round 5 image 1round 5 image 2round 5 image 3round 5 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1(kept as it was)

2cars racing down an empty road, add a dirt road in a desert landscape with mountains at sunset, add one rally car kicking up dust

3cars racing down an empty road, add a busy city street during daytime with vintage 1950s cars and some pedestrians on the sidewalks

4(kept as it was)

Round 7

the width of the road, the number of cars, the year/model of cars, the time of day, the location/scenery

19 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.00

round 7 image 1round 7 image 2round 7 image 3round 7 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1(kept as it was)

2Change the year/model of the cars to classic 1950s models.

3Change the time of day to a sunny morning.

4(kept as it was)

Round 8 Accepted

the width of the road, the number of cars, the year/model of cars, the time of day, the location/scenery

19 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.00

varied ★★★★★ matched ★★★★★

round 8 image 1round 8 image 2round 8 image 3round 8 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1(kept as it was)

2(kept as it was)

3(kept as it was)

4change the road width to make it a wide highway<br>change the time to afternoon<br>change the style to modern McLaren models

Participant 7 · Sep 25, 08:32

children dancing on stage in a dance recital

Prompt changed

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Participant 7 · Sep 25, 08:35

children dancing on stage in a dance recital, wearing costumes

Prompt changed

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis. The participant revised the prompt; it was: “children dancing on stage in a dance recital”.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Participant 7 · Sep 25, 08:37

children dancing on stage in a dance recital, wearing dance costumes instead of regular clothes

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis. The participant revised the prompt; it was: “children dancing on stage in a dance recital, wearing costumes”.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Accepted

Very the level of synchronization between the children's arm and leg movements

12 words

new set · diversity 0.56

varied ★★★★☆ matched ★★★★☆

“The images match my prompt, my edited prompt, and the axes request. I think the differences across the images are subtle but still good.”

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1children dancing on stage in a dance recital, wearing dance costumes instead of regular clothes, each child moving their arms and legs in completely different, random, unsynchronized motions.

2children dancing on stage in a dance recital, wearing dance costumes instead of regular clothes, moving with perfect uniformity; every arm and leg synchronized to exact same beat.

3children dancing on stage in a dance recital, wearing dance costumes instead of regular clothes, mostly synchronized but with slight individual flair in hand gestures.

4children dancing on stage in a dance recital, wearing dance costumes instead of regular clothes, highly synchronized leg movements with varied, artistic arm positions.

Participant 5 · Sep 25, 08:41

a teal lobster lifting weights in an underwater bowling alley

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Accepted

lobster size, weights, angle

4 words

new set · diversity 1.00

varied ★★★☆☆ matched ★★★★★

“Pictures matched the prompt provided. The added differences didn't come back as expected. 3 of the 4 images still use the same kind of weights.”

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1a teal lobster lifting weights in an underwater bowling alley. Close-up portrait of a small, cute, tiny teal lobster with big eyes, smiling, lifting a tiny dumbbell, colorful bowling pins in background.

2a teal lobster lifting weights in an underwater bowling alley. Huge giant massive teal lobster, muscular, lifting heavy barbell with lots of weight plates, intense focus, underwater bowling alley with lanes and balls.

3a teal lobster lifting weights in an underwater bowling alley. Side profile view, teal lobster lifting overhead weights, dynamic action pose, underwater bowling alley, spectators, fish, neon lights, bowling balls rolling.

4a teal lobster lifting weights in an underwater bowling alley. Three teal lobsters: one lifting weights, one bowling, one cheering. Various sizes, colorful gear, weights, banners, bubbles, aquatic plants.

Participant 6 · Sep 25, 08:41

a family get-together for a backyard barbecue

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1

the perspective/camera angle of the scene, the time of day, cultural background of the people and food, the placement of the barbecue relative to the framing of the image

29 words

new set · diversity 0.67

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1a family get-together for a backyard barbecue, wide shot from back of patio, sunny afternoon, diverse group having fun, grill in center, burgers, veggies, laughter.

2a family get-together for a backyard barbecue, low angle looking up at smiling faces, evening twilight with string lights, Asian family, BBQ skewers, rice, lanterns.

3a family get-together for a backyard barbecue, close-up eye level of cooks at grill, noon bright sun, Hispanic family, tacos, beans, corn, colorful tablecloths.

4a family get-together for a backyard barbecue, high angle drone view of whole yard, late sunset orange sky, family and friends dining, large smoker grill side left.

Round 2

the perspective/camera angle of the scene, the time of day, cultural background of the people and food, the placement of the barbecue relative to the framing of the image

29 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.89

round 2 image 1round 2 image 2round 2 image 3round 2 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1(kept as it was)

2a family get-together for a backyard barbecue, add a wide-angle view with a drone perspective looking down on the scene, change the time to twilight, add Asian faces and serve vegetable skewers and buns

3a family get-together for a backyard barbecue, change the perspective to a medium shot from behind the grill, add Mexican cultural background with tacos and beans as food

4(kept as it was)

Round 3 Accepted

the perspective/camera angle of the scene, the time of day, cultural background of the people and food, the placement of the barbecue relative to the framing of the image

29 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.11

varied ★★★★★ matched ★★★★★

“they varied the placement of the barbecue, but the barbecue is too prominent in the images”

round 3 image 1round 3 image 2round 3 image 3round 3 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1(kept as it was)

2Increase the distance of the camera to show a wide, high-angle view of the entire backyard scene, including a nearby house, maintaining bright daylight.

3(kept as it was)

4(kept as it was)

Participant 7 · Sep 25, 08:43

a bride-to-be modeling a wedding gown in a bridal shop as her mother looks on

Prompt changed

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Participant 7 · Sep 25, 08:46

a bride-to-be modeling a wedding gown in a mirror at a bridal shop as her mother looks on

Left after 2 rounds

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis. The participant revised the prompt; it was: “a bride-to-be modeling a wedding gown in a bridal shop as her mother looks on”.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1

Vary the ethnicity of the bride in each image

9 words

new set · diversity 0.56

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1a bride-to-be modeling a wedding gown in a mirror at a bridal shop as her mother looks on; bride is a young South Asian woman with dark hair and traditional jewelry, mother watching lovingly

2a bride-to-be modeling a wedding gown in a mirror at a bridal shop as her mother looks on; bride is a young Black woman with curly hair and vibrant lipstick, mother admiring the dress

3a bride-to-be modeling a wedding gown in a mirror at a bridal shop as her mother looks on; bride is a middle-aged Hispanic woman with long brown hair, mother looking on with pride

4a bride-to-be modeling a wedding gown in a mirror at a bridal shop as her mother looks on; bride is a young East Asian woman with a neat bun, mother observing the elegant gown

Round 2

Vary the ethnicity of the bride in each image

9 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.56

round 2 image 1round 2 image 2round 2 image 3round 2 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1make the bride East Asian with her mother remaining the same

2make the bride Black with her mother remaining the same

3make the bride Caucasian with her mother remaining the same

4make the bride Middle Eastern with her mother remaining the same

Participant 5 · Sep 25, 08:45

a group of troublemakers sneaking into a rusty old dumpster located behind a police station

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Accepted

group size, group clothing, dumpster

5 words

new set · diversity 0.67

varied ★★★☆☆ matched ★★★☆☆

“Prompt wasn't followed exactly. Results came back in front of police station; rather than behind. When I asked for the dumpster to change, 3 of the 4 images still returned a dumpster that looks very similar to each other.”

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1a group of troublemakers sneaking into a rusty old dumpster located behind a police station. Two mischievous kids in bright yellow raincoats and boots, tiptoeing quietly at night under moonlight.

2a group of troublemakers sneaking into a rusty old dumpster located behind a police station. Six rebellious teens in hooded black jackets and jeans, laughing while hiding behind the dumpster, police lights flashing.

3a group of troublemakers sneaking into a rusty old dumpster located behind a police station. A large gang of ten diverse young adults in colorful streetwear and caps, climbing the dumpster lid.

4a group of troublemakers sneaking into a rusty old dumpster located behind a police station. A massive towering dumpster made of gold and rust, surrounded by five masked hackers in futuristic armor sneaking inside.

Participant 5 · Sep 25, 08:50

a preacher with face tattoos playing video games inside of a cave

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Accepted

cave, angle, controller, face tattoos, ethnicity, facial expression

8 words

new set · diversity 1.00

varied ★★★★☆ matched ★★★★★

“Really impressed for how well the image generator handled all of the changes I requested. The facial expressions were the only thing I would've liked to see a better variation of.”

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1a preacher with face tattoos playing video games inside of a cave. Close-up portrait of the preacher, intense face tattoos, serious expression, beard, robe, holding a game controller, gaming screen visible.

2a preacher with face tattoos playing video games inside of a cave. Wide angle shot of a large cave interior, preacher with face tattoos gaming, colorful lights, arcade machines, other people watching, diverse crowd.

3a preacher with face tattoos playing video games inside of a cave. Asian preacher man with intricate face tattoos, playing video games, cave background, vibrant controller, focused expression, gaming setup.

4a preacher with face tattoos playing video games inside of a cave. Elderly Black preacher with face tattoos, wearing sunglasses, laughing happily while holding a controller, cave walls with murals, games posters.

Their questionnaire

Useful to say what varies: ★★★★★

Slider behaved as expected: ★★★★☆

Enjoyed the task: ★★★★★

Preferred: Generate new

Uses image generators: A few times

Wanted to vary but could not: I don't think so. It handled everything I asked of it.

Other: Thanks for the opportunity to participate in this study. I enjoyed it!

Would do more: Yes

Participant 6 · Sep 25, 08:51

a father and son fishing on a boat in water

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1

the time of day, the body of water, the physical positions the people are in, the cultural background of the people, the size of the boat

26 words

new set · diversity 0.67

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A father and son fishing on a boat in water at bright midday sun, clear blue sky, calm ocean waves, happy faces, colorful boats, fishing rods.

2A father and son fishing on a boat in water during sunset, orange and purple sky, serious expressions, small wooden rowboat, serene lake background, fishing gear.

3A father and son fishing on a boat in water at night, moonlight on calm river, wearing warm coats, lanterns glowing, starry sky, quiet atmosphere, fishing rods.

4A father and son fishing on a boat in water, tropical island background, wearing traditional Southeast Asian clothing, vibrant patterns, large modern fishing boat, bright daylight.

Round 2

the time of day, the body of water, the physical positions the people are in, the cultural background of the people, the size of the boat

26 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.00

round 2 image 1round 2 image 2round 2 image 3round 2 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1(kept as it was)

2change the environment to a calm lake during sunset, and the physical positions of the father and son to sitting down together.

3(kept as it was)

4(kept as it was)

Round 3

the time of day, the body of water, the physical positions the people are in, the cultural background of the people, the size of the boat

26 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.22

round 3 image 1round 3 image 2round 3 image 3round 3 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1(kept as it was)

2move them to sitting down on the right side of the boat and change the body of water to a calm river at night with a lantern.

3(kept as it was)

4change the physical positions to stand side-by-side at the bow, and change the body of water to a teal tropical ocean.

Round 4 Accepted

the time of day, the body of water, the physical positions the people are in, the cultural background of the people, the size of the boat

26 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.56

varied ★★★★☆ matched ★★★★★

“the positions are varied, but they are either both sitting or both standing.”

round 4 image 1round 4 image 2round 4 image 3round 4 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1(kept as it was)

2change the body of water to a calm dark river at dusk with trees on the shore

3(kept as it was)

4(kept as it was)

Participant 7 · Sep 25, 08:53

sailboats in a harbor on Lake Michigan

Stopped before choosing an axis

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Participant 7 · Sep 25, 08:55

A shelf of pantry staples in a grocery store, with labels clearly visible

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Accepted

Each image should have one type of item, and they should be different between the images.

16 words

new set · diversity 0.56

varied ★★★★★ matched ★★★★★

“This is really good. The images match my prompt and the axes request.”

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A shelf of pantry staples in a grocery store, with labels clearly visible. Only canned goods, including soup, beans, and tuna, neatly arranged.

2A shelf of pantry staples in a grocery store, with labels clearly visible. Only boxes of cereal, including corn flakes, oat bran, and bran flakes, displayed.

3A shelf of pantry staples in a grocery store, with labels clearly visible. Only jars of pickles, jams, and sauces, with bright colorful labels.

4A shelf of pantry staples in a grocery store, with labels clearly visible. Only bags of flour, sugar, rice, and pasta, stacked neatly.

Participant 6 · Sep 25, 08:57

a group of students taking a painting class

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1

the cultural diversity of the class, the angle we see the students, the painting tools used, the time of day/lighting

20 words

new set · diversity 0.22

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1a group of students taking a painting class, diverse cultures from around the world, frontal viewing angle, oil paints and brushes, bright sunny daylight

2a group of students taking a painting class, diverse cultures, low camera angle looking up, colorful digital tablets and styluses, dramatic evening interior lighting

3a group of students taking a painting class, mixed cultural backgrounds, high angle overhead shot, traditional watercolor sets and brushes, soft golden hour light

4a group of students taking a painting class, rich cultural diversity, side profile angle, wood carving chisels and mud tools, dark stormy night

Round 2

the cultural diversity of the class, the angle we see the students, the painting tools used, the time of day/lighting

20 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.44

round 2 image 1round 2 image 2round 2 image 3round 2 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1add diverse students from different ethnic backgrounds and vary the perspective to a high-angle shot looking down at the easels

2change the participants to a culturally diverse group and shift the viewpoint to a side profile of the student in the center

3(kept as it was)

4make the class multicultural and change the time of day to dusk with warm golden hour lighting

Round 3 Accepted

the cultural diversity of the class, the angle we see the students, the painting tools used, the time of day/lighting

20 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.78

varied ★★★☆☆ matched ★★★★★

“Many of the students still appear to be of similar cultural background”

round 3 image 1round 3 image 2round 3 image 3round 3 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1(kept as it was)

2a group of students taking a painting class, view from a side angle focusing on a student painting a portrait, include traditional Asian calligraphy tools like brushes and ink alongside western paints

3a group of students taking a painting class, view from a high-angle looking down, diverse group of students including individuals in casual streetwear and traditional garments, include students using bright acrylics and collaborative art supplies

4(kept as it was)

Their questionnaire

Useful to say what varies: ★★★★★

Slider behaved as expected: ★★★☆☆

Enjoyed the task: ★★★★★

Preferred: Edit these

Uses image generators: Monthly

Wanted to vary but could not: There were certain aspects of generated images I would like to keep, like the specific position of a person or object but I could only keep the entire image or nothing at all.

Would do more: Yes

Participant 7 · Sep 25, 08:59

A city council meeting, from the perspective of the council, looking toward the audience. There should be one city resident speaking to the council from a lecturn and they have a service animal with them.

Prompt changed

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Participant 7 · Sep 25, 09:03

A city council meeting, from the perspective of the council, looking toward the audience. There should be one city resident speaking to the council from a lecturn and they have a service animal with them.We should see the faces of the audience, not the council.

Prompt changed

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis. The participant revised the prompt; it was: “A city council meeting, from the perspective of the council, looking toward the audience. There should be one city resident speaking to the council from a lecturn and they have a service animal with them.”.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Participant 7 · Sep 25, 09:04

Workers replacing a roof on a building

Left after 4 rounds

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis. The participant revised the prompt; it was: “A city council meeting, from the perspective of the council, looking toward the audience. There should be one city resident speaking to the council from a lecturn and they have a service animal with them.We should see the faces of the audience, not the council.”.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1

Each image should have a differnt type of building

9 words

new set · diversity 0.89

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1Workers replacing a roof on a building. Classic white Victorian house with red tiles, workers in safety gear installing new shingles, blue sky, tools, ladders.

2Workers replacing a roof on a building. Modern sleek glass skyscraper, workers replacing metal roof panels, construction equipment, city background, safety helmets.

3Workers replacing a roof on a building. Large rustic wooden barn with broken roof, workers fixing it, rustic tools, rural landscape, cows nearby, sunny day.

4Workers replacing a roof on a building. Futuristic dome-shaped space station or high-tech facility, workers upgrading roof panels, sci-fi background, stars, neon lights.

Round 2

Each image should have a differnt type of building

9 words

new set · diversity 0.22

round 2 image 1round 2 image 2round 2 image 3round 2 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1Workers replacing a roof on a small wooden cottage building.

2Workers replacing a roof on a large modern glass skyscraper building.

3Workers replacing a roof on a historic brick church building.

4Workers replacing a roof on a luxury seaside hotel building.

Round 3

Each image should have a differnt type of building

9 words

new set · diversity 0.11

round 3 image 1round 3 image 2round 3 image 3round 3 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1Workers replacing a roof on a small wooden cottage<br>

2Workers replacing a roof on a large glass skyscraper<br>

3Workers replacing a roof on a historic Victorian stone house<br>

4Workers replacing a roof on a modern industrial warehouse<br>

Round 4

Each image should have a differnt type of building

9 words

new set · diversity 0.44

round 4 image 1round 4 image 2round 4 image 3round 4 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1Workers replacing a roof on a small wooden cottage building. Tools visible, blue sky.

2Workers replacing a roof on a large modern skyscraper building. Safety harnesses, urban background.

3Workers replacing a roof on an old Victorian brick house building. Ladder, shingles, sunny day.

4Workers replacing a roof on a futuristic glass tower building. Drone view, sleek architecture.

Their questionnaire

Useful to say what varies: ★★★★★

Slider behaved as expected: ★★★★☆

Enjoyed the task: ★★★★★

Preferred: Generate new

Uses image generators: A few times

Wanted to vary but could not: No, the tool made the changes I requested.

Other: When I added to or changed the prompt, I couldn't see the new set of images until I typed in the box to request the axes to change. Only then could I see the images from the prompt, because they would appear on the right under "Original pictures" and I had the option to "go back to these". I think that happend in three of the rounds. And, maybe I used too many words in one of the prompts, but it wasn't able to generate images of a city council meeting from the perspective of the council looking out toward the audience. The images returned were from the audience, facing toward the council. Overall the tool is amazing and very fun to use, but I would need more sets to get comfortable with it. Please message me if my feedback isn't clear.

Would do more: Yes

Participant 8 · Sep 25, 09:13

A group of three people sharing a plate of nachos

Prompt changed

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Participant 8 · Sep 25, 09:17

A group of three people seated at a table sharing a plate of nachos

Prompt changed

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis. The participant revised the prompt; it was: “A group of three people sharing a plate of nachos”.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Participant 8 · Sep 25, 09:18

A group of three people seated at a table sharing a plate of nachos. The table should be clearly seen.

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis. The participant revised the prompt; it was: “A group of three people seated at a table sharing a plate of nachos”.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1

the background scenery

3 words

new set · diversity 1.00

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A group of three people seated at a table sharing a plate of nachos. The table should be clearly seen. Three friends laughing, close-up, detailed faces, happy expressions, colorful nachos, cheese, salsa, drinks on the table.

2A group of three people seated at a table sharing a plate of nachos. The table should be clearly seen. Indoor cozy cafe background, bookshelves, plants, warm lights, posters, chalkboard menu, three diverse friends eating nachos.

3A group of three people seated at a table sharing a plate of nachos. The table should be clearly seen. Beach sunset background, ocean waves, palm trees, sand, blue sky, three people enjoying nachos together, summer vibes.

4A group of three people seated at a table sharing a plate of nachos. The table should be clearly seen. Night city skyline background, tall buildings, neon lights, stars, moon, three people at table eating nachos, festive atmosphere.

Round 2

the background scenery

3 words

edited the previous set · diversity 1.00

round 2 image 1round 2 image 2round 2 image 3round 2 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A group of three people seated at a table sharing a plate of nachos. The table should be clearly seen. Add a lush garden with flowers and trees in the background.

2A group of three people seated at a table sharing a plate of nachos. The table should be clearly seen. Add a cozy cafe interior with bookshelves, hanging plants, and a menu board in the background.

3A group of three people seated at a table sharing a plate of nachos. The table should be clearly seen. Add a tropical beach sunset with palm trees and ocean waves in the background.

4A group of three people seated at a table sharing a plate of nachos. The table should be clearly seen. Add a vibrant city skyline with neon lights and a full moon in the background.

Round 3

the ages of the people

5 words

new set · diversity 0.67

round 3 image 1round 3 image 2round 3 image 3round 3 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A group of three young children seated at a table sharing a plate of nachos. The table should be clearly seen. They are laughing and eating together in a colorful room.

2A group of three young adults in their twenties seated at a table sharing a plate of nachos. The table should be clearly seen. Casual clothes, smiling, modern restaurant setting.

3A group of three middle-aged adults seated at a table sharing a plate of nachos. The table should be clearly seen. Professional attire, warm lighting, cozy dining atmosphere.

4A group of three elderly people seated at a table sharing a plate of nachos. The table should be clearly seen. Glasses, gray hair, joyful expressions, comfortable home setting.

Round 5 Accepted

the ages of the people

5 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.67

varied ★★★☆☆ matched ★★★★★

“I wanted a mix of ages within each picture rather than the same age in each picture.”

round 5 image 1round 5 image 2round 5 image 3round 5 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A group of three people seated at a table sharing a plate of nachos. The table should be clearly seen. Make the group appear to be elderly friends, with gray hair and age spots.

2A group of three people seated at a table sharing a plate of nachos. The table should be clearly seen. Make them appear to be young teenagers, with youthful faces and casual streetwear.

3A group of three people seated at a table sharing a plate of nachos. The table should be clearly seen. Make the group appear to be middle-aged adults in their 30s, dressed professionally but casually.

4A group of three people seated at a table sharing a plate of nachos. The table should be clearly seen. Make the group appear to be three very young children, excitedly eating.

Participant 9 · Sep 25, 09:21

an outdoor table with a clear pitcher of an adult beverage and a glass half full of said beverage

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Accepted

different types of beverages

4 words

new set · diversity 0.67

varied ★★★★★ matched ★★★★★

“it provided more variation in drink types compared to the first set”

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1an outdoor table with a clear pitcher of an adult beverage and a glass half full of said beverage. The beverage is a vibrant red wine, setting sun golden hour, rustic patio.

2an outdoor table with a clear pitcher of an adult beverage and a glass half full of said beverage. The beverage is a frothy golden beer with foam, picnic blanket, summer grass.

3an outdoor table with a clear pitcher of an adult beverage and a glass half full of said beverage. The beverage is a blue tropical cocktail with ice, palm trees, ocean background.

4an outdoor table with a clear pitcher of an adult beverage and a glass half full of said beverage. The beverage is a rich green smoothie or lime punch, jungle guests, exotic flowers.

Participant 9 · Sep 25, 09:25

a tropical beach

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1

different types of trees or plants

6 words

new set · diversity 0.89

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1a tropical beach, sunny sky, blue ocean, white sand, clear water, relaxed vacation vibe, palm trees swaying in the wind, colorful umbrellas, beachgoers enjoying the sun.

2a tropical beach, lush jungle background, exotic flowers, vibrant orchids, ferns, dense green foliage, colorful flamingos, bright blue sky, serene ocean waves, paradise island.

3a tropical beach, coastal cliffs, coconut palms, banana trees, sugarcane fields, colorful huts, fishermen boats, vibrant sunset, seagulls flying, happy tourists on shore.

4a tropical beach, cactus gardens near shore, succulents, tropical vines, hibiscus flowers, colorful parrots, coral reef visible underwater, clear blue sky, sandy golden beach.

Round 2 Accepted

different types of trees or plants

6 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.89

varied ★★★☆☆ matched ★★★☆☆

“It varied the trees a bit but the last picture is a desert and not a beach”

round 2 image 1round 2 image 2round 2 image 3round 2 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1a tropical beach add some pine trees and a small wooden cabin in the background

2a tropical beach add vibrant tropical flowers, ferns and banana plants in the foreground with two flamingos walking

3a tropical beach add some bunkers and a banyan tree with people walking under it near the water

4a tropical beach add a desert garden with cacti, succulents, and a parrot flying overhead

Participant 8 · Sep 25, 09:25

Two children and a dog playing in a park

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Accepted

the positions of the children

5 words

new set · diversity 1.00

varied ★★★★★ matched ★★★☆☆

“Picture number 2 added and extra child and a dog. The children in image number 3 look unrealistic. The variety in positioning is good however.”

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1Two children and a dog playing in a park. A young toddler girl and a baby boy playing with a happy golden retriever dog. Colorful balloons, grass, flowers, smiling faces, toys.

2Two children and a dog playing in a park. Two older teenage boys playing frisbee and running with a cute dog. Park bench, swings, other kids in background, sunny day, blue sky.

3Two children and a dog playing in a park. A little Asian girl and a Hispanic boy playing tag with a small puppy. Vibrant clothes, cartoonish dog, picnic blanket, ice cream, laughter.

4Two children and a dog playing in a park. Two girls sitting on grass watching a dog play fetch. One girl has long hair, one has ponytail. Dog chasing ball, trees, flowers, playground.

Participant 9 · Sep 25, 09:27

American chinese food

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Accepted

not all of them should look soupy, think more like panda express

12 words

new set · diversity 0.44

varied ★★★★☆ matched ★★★★☆

“Could have had different dishes than 2 with chicken wings”

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1American chinese food, numerous dry crispy fried chicken pieces, sesame chicken, lettuce wraps, panda express style, dry not soupy, vibrant colors.

2American chinese food, plate of dry honey garlic wings, crispy wonton strips, crispy fried appetizers, no broth, panda express aesthetic, appetizing textures.

3American chinese food, serving of dry orange chicken, crispy shrimp, egg roll wraps, steamed buns, no liquid soup, dry and crunchy textures, panda express.

4American chinese food, platter of dry lo mein noodles tossed dry, crispy lettuce wrap, fried rice, authentic panda express style, zero soup, fully texturized.

Participant 10 · Sep 25, 09:30

A cute animal playing in a shady forest amongst the trees

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Accepted

Different types of animal

4 words

new set · diversity 0.78

varied ★★★★★ matched ★★★★☆

“I am happy with the results here overall. It varied the animals relatively well, even if it chose ones that don't super belong in the scene. They are all at least different as requested. I would have expected the poses of varied animals to be more different to each other, and the sizes of the animals to be more varied overall. I know this isn't directly specified in the axis, but feel like its implied by the request for varying animals. I used generate new image and the new generations look very much like the original set also.”

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A cute animal playing in a shady forest amongst the trees. A fluffy white puppy running happily, playing with fallen leaves, sunlight filtering through trees.

2A cute animal playing in a shady forest amongst the trees. An adorable orange tabby kitten chasing butterflies among mossy logs and ferns in a magical forest.

3A cute animal playing in a shady forest amongst the trees. A baby panda rolling on grass, eating bamboo, surrounded by towering trees and dappled shade light.

4A cute animal playing in a shady forest amongst the trees. A cheerful little raccoon digging in the dirt, holding a flower, with birds and colorful forest background.

Participant 8 · Sep 25, 09:30

A lone person sitting on a park bench beside a river.

Prompt changed

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Participant 8 · Sep 25, 09:32

A lone person seen from a distance sitting on a park bench beside a river.

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis. The participant revised the prompt; it was: “A lone person sitting on a park bench beside a river.”.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1

the angle of view

4 words

new set · diversity 1.00

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A lone person seen from a distance sitting on a park bench beside a river. Back view of the person, silhouetted against a beautiful sunset sky, river flowing, trees, birds, peaceful atmosphere.

2A lone person seen from a distance sitting on a park bench beside a river. Front face view of the person, looking thoughtful, wearing casual clothes, backpack, river and park scenery in background.

3A lone person seen from a distance sitting on a park bench beside a river. Over-the-shoulder side view of the person reading a book, park bench, river, boats, willow trees, ducks.

4A lone person seen from a distance sitting on a park bench beside a river. High angle bird's eye view showing the person on bench, path, grass, river winding away, city lights in distance.

Round 2

the angle of view

4 words

edited the previous set · diversity 1.00

round 2 image 1round 2 image 2round 2 image 3round 2 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A lone person seen from a distance sitting on a park bench beside a river. Add a camera in the foreground with a wide-angle lens capturing the entire scene including city skyline in background.

2A lone person seen from a distance sitting on a park bench beside a river. Add a side profile of the person looking towards the river, with some facial features visible.

3A lone person seen from a distance sitting on a park bench beside a river. Add the person reading a book and add a close-up view with some ducks and boats in the foreground.

4A lone person seen from a distance sitting on a park bench beside a river. Add a动态 first-person perspective of the person on the bench looking out at the evening city lights with a lamp post in the foreground.

Round 3

the type of bench

4 words

edited the previous set · diversity 1.00

round 3 image 1round 3 image 2round 3 image 3round 3 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A lone person seen from a distance sitting on a park bench beside a river. Add an ornate, vintage-style wrought iron bench with decorative patterns behind them.

2A lone person seen from a distance sitting on a park bench beside a river. Add a modern, colorful bench with bold geometric designs and planters beside it.

3A lone person seen from a distance sitting on a park bench beside a river. Add a wooden bench with a small table and some books nearby.

4A lone person seen from a distance sitting on a park bench beside a river. Add a child-friendly bench with bright colors and some animals around.

Round 4

the type of bench

4 words

new set · diversity 1.00

round 4 image 1round 4 image 2round 4 image 3round 4 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A lone person seen from a distance sitting on a park bench beside a river. The person is alone, far away, sitting on a simple wooden bench with metal legs, river flowing, trees, sunset.

2A lone person seen from a distance sitting on a park bench beside a river. The person is alone, sitting on a large, colorful, ornate decorative bench with cushions and flowers, river, boats.

3A lone person seen from a distance sitting on a park bench beside a river. The person is alone, sitting on a modern black leather lounge bench with armrests, river, city lights, moon.

4A lone person seen from a distance sitting on a park bench beside a river. The person is alone, sitting on a bright yellow double-seater bench, holding a book, river, ducks, willow trees.

Round 6 Accepted

the type of bench

4 words

edited the previous set · diversity 1.00

varied ★★★★★ matched ★★★★★

“The 'type' of bench edit produced a good variety of benches.”

round 6 image 1round 6 image 2round 6 image 3round 6 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A lone person seen from a distance sitting on a vintage wooden park bench beside a river. Add some books and a hat on the bench.

2A lone person seen from a distance sitting on a modern, sleek metal bench with colorful geometric patterns beside a river.

3A lone person seen from a distance sitting on a bench made of wicker and cushions beside a river, with a small table next to it.

4A lone person seen from a distance sitting on a child-friendly bench shaped like animals with toys around it beside a river.

Participant 9 · Sep 25, 09:30

a building on fire

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Accepted

different building styles

3 words

new set · diversity 0.78

varied ★★★★★ matched ★★★★★

“it gave 4 very distinct buildings like I was looking for.”

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A building on fire. A classic Victorian-style brick mansion with tall chimneys, ornate windows, flames raging, smoke filling the night sky, dramatic scene.

2A building on fire. A futuristic glass skyscraper with neon lights sparks, metal structure collapsing, intense orange fire, emergency vehicles below, cyberpunk city background.

3A building on fire. A rustic wooden cabin in a forest, thatched roof burning, trucks and firefighters arriving, warm fire glow, stars, werewolves watching from trees.

4A building on fire. An ancient Greek temple with stone columns, marble structure igniting, dramatic clouds, fire pouring from pediment, historical ruins, cinematic lighting.

Participant 9 · Sep 25, 09:32

monkeys swinging from things

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1

different objects being swung from

5 words

new set · diversity 1.00

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1monkeys swinging from things. Many playful monkeys swinging from colorful vines, branches, and trees in a lush jungle. Happy monkeys, vibrant feathers, dynamic action, swinging motion.

2monkeys swinging from things. Monkeys swinging from cars, buses, trucks, and motorcycles parked in a busy town square. Monkeys holding onto mirrors, roofs, bumpers, laughing joyfully.

3monkeys swinging from things. Monkeys swinging from lamps, street signs, traffic lights, clocks, and umbrellas in a magical city night. Moonlit sky, stars, colorful clothes on monkeys.

4monkeys swinging from things. Monkeys swinging from jet planes, helicopters, rockets, and futuristic gadgets in space. Astronaut monkeys, stars, planets, galaxies, sci-fi background.

Round 2 Accepted

different objects, not a rope in each one, think chandeliers or monkey bars

13 words

new set · diversity 1.00

varied ★★★★☆ matched ★★★★★

“finally got different objects being swung from, they look very fake though”

round 2 image 1round 2 image 2round 2 image 3round 2 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1monkeys swinging from things. Cute monkeys hanging from a thick strong rope, swinging in the air, joyful expressions, colorful clothes, jungle background, birds, flowers, sunny day.

2monkeys swinging from things. Monkeys playing on big colorful chandeliers with crystals and lights, swinging from chains, happy monkeys, stars, magical night sky, fairies.

3monkeys swinging from things. Monkeys on monkey bars made of wood and metal, climbing and swinging, gym style, bright colors, spectators watching, jungle theme, energetic.

4monkeys swinging from things. Monkeys hanging from large wooden bridges, logs, and barrels, playing with balls, baskets, vibrant costumes, rainforest background, waterfalls.

Their questionnaire

Useful to say what varies: ★★★★☆

Slider behaved as expected: ★★★★☆

Enjoyed the task: ★★★★★

Preferred: Generate new

Uses image generators: Weekly or more

Wanted to vary but could not: More realistic looking pictures.

Other: na

Would do more: Yes

Participant 10 · Sep 25, 09:40

A photorealistic city skyline, showing a modern and futuristic city from the future located on a distant planet.

Left after 3 rounds

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1

Styles of buildings, based on different genres of sci-fi

9 words

new set · diversity 1.00

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A photorealistic city skyline, showing a modern and futuristic city from the future located on a distant planet. Cinematic night view, stunning neon lights, volcanic mountains in background, alien landscape, stars, moons, spaceships docking.

2A photorealistic city skyline, showing a modern and futuristic city from the future located on a distant planet. High-tech cyberpunk style, deadly labs, robots, holographic ads, flying cars, dark moody atmosphere, loyal veterans guarding gates.

3A photorealistic city skyline, showing a modern and futuristic city from the future located on a distant planet. Elegant white marble architecture, golden domes, classical columns, gardens, water fountains, royal guards, sunny day.

4A photorealistic city skyline, showing a modern and futuristic city from the future located on a distant planet. Savage industrial sci-fi, massive工程机械,smokestacks,邂cksy docks, погодная техника,drones, soldiers, alien chic city vibe.

Round 2

Styles of buildings, based on different genres of sci-fi

9 words

edited the previous set · diversity 1.00

round 2 image 1round 2 image 2round 2 image 3round 2 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A photorealistic city skyline, showing a modern and futuristic city from the future located on a distant planet. Add Japanese-inspired debating architecture with cherry blossoms and neon signs in the foreground.

2A photorealistic city skyline, showing a modern and futuristic city from the future located on a distant planet. Add cyberpunk elements with rainy streets, hackers, AR holograms, and gritty details in the foreground.

3A photorealistic city skyline, showing a modern and futuristic city from the future located on a distant planet. Add classical European palaces with domes, gardens, and people in formal wear in the foreground.

4A photorealistic city skyline, showing a modern and futuristic city from the future located on a distant planet. Add industrial elements, construction sites, heavy machinery, and workers in the foreground.

Round 3

Styles and shapes of buildings, based on different genres of sci-fi

11 words

edited the previous set · diversity 1.00

round 3 image 1round 3 image 2round 3 image 3round 3 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A photorealistic city skyline, showing a modern and futuristic city from the future located on a distant planet. Add steampunk elements with intricate gears, brass accents, and airship docks in the foreground.

2A photorealistic city skyline, showing a modern and futuristic city from the future located on a distant planet. Add cyberpunk Preise in the foreground with neon signs, holograms, vendors, and rain.

3A photorealistic city skyline, showing a modern and futuristic city from the future located on a distant planet. Add classical Greek and Roman style buildings with domes and columns in the foreground, add some people in evening gowns.

4A photorealistic city skyline, showing a modern and futuristic city from the future located on a distant planet. Add industrial construction zones with cranes, robots, and workers in the foreground adding a gritty texture to the buildings.

Participant 8 · Sep 25, 09:42

a backyard garden filled with lush foliage and a variety of flowers.

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Accepted

the colour and amount of flowers

6 words

new set · diversity 1.00

varied ★★★★★ matched ★★★★★

“A great variation resulted from just the one prompt. More variation was given than was requested such as the style of artwork and the time of day.”

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1a backyard garden filled with lush foliage and a variety of flowers. Focus on green leaves, bushes, trees, a wooden fence, a swing set, a cozy house in background, butterflies, bees, happy atmosphere.

2a backyard garden filled with lush foliage and a variety of flowers. Vibrant red, pink, orange, and yellow flowers in full bloom, colorful tulips, roses, daisies, sunflowers, diverse floral arrangements.

3a backyard garden filled with lush foliage and a variety of flowers. Night time garden, glowing moonlight, purple and blue flowers, white lanterns, fireflies, stars, magical atmosphere, path with stones.

4a backyard garden filled with lush foliage and a variety of flowers. Black and white color scheme, monochrome garden, grayscale flowers, green leaves, stone statues, elegant vibe, detailed foliage.

Participant 8 · Sep 25, 09:47

A busy market scene

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1

different ages in time

4 words

new set · diversity 1.00

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A busy market scene. Vibrant colors, many stalls selling fruits, clothes, spices. Busy crowd of diverse people shopping, vendors shouting, animals, carts, flags, lively atmosphere, day time.

2A busy market scene. Futuristic cyberpunk market, neon lights, flying drones. Young trendy people in fashion, sci-fi vendors, advanced technology, space age stalls, energetic youth crowd.

3A busy market scene. Vintage 1920s era market, old-fashioned clothes, hats, umbrellas. Elderly wise vendors, mature shoppers, horse carriages, classic cars, warm sunset lighting.

4A busy market scene. Family-oriented market, parents with young children, toddlers playing. Multi-generational crowd: babies, kids, teenagers, adults, seniors smiling, festive decorations.

Round 2

different ages in time

4 words

edited the previous set · diversity 1.00

round 2 image 1round 2 image 2round 2 image 3round 2 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A busy market scene with elderly people shopping and vendors in traditional attire, add a vintage background with old-fashioned buildings

2A busy market scene with young adults and teenagers, add futuristic elements like drones and neon signs

3A busy market scene with a family including a man, woman, and several children of various ages, add some festive decorations

4A busy market scene with diverse people including a young man and a middle-aged woman, add a clock tower and daytime lighting

Round 3 Accepted

different ages in time

4 words

new set · diversity 1.00

varied ★★★★★ matched ★★★★★

round 3 image 1round 3 image 2round 3 image 3round 3 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A busy market scene. Vibrant colors, many stalls, vendors selling fruits, clothes, spices. Crowded people shopping, lively atmosphere, colorful umbrellas, signs, animals, carts, busy street.

2A busy market scene. Future cyberpunk style, neon lights,高科技 stalls. Young diverse people in futuristic clothes, selling gadgets, drones, VR headsets, robots, space items, energetic youth.

3A busy market scene. Elderly wise people shopping, old-fashioned clothing, vintage cars, classic stalls. Seniors bargaining, grandchildren helping, nostalgic vibe, warm sunset, horses, carts.

4A busy market scene. Families with children of various ages, parents pushing strollers, kids playing, colorful dresses. Mid-aged vendors, festive decorations, food stalls, joyous celebration.

Their questionnaire

Useful to say what varies: ★★★★★

Slider behaved as expected: ★★★☆☆

Enjoyed the task: ★★★★★

Preferred: Generate new

Uses image generators: Monthly

Wanted to vary but could not: One of the images produced cartoon animals and I wanted to keep this particular image but delete the cartoon animals but was unable to.

Other: It would be good to be able to choose one of the generated images to edit.

Would do more: Yes

Participant 11 · Sep 25, 09:48

female pop star performing on a stage

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Accepted

race of singer, hair color of singer, stage venue, crowd

10 words

new set · diversity 0.78

varied ★★★★☆ matched ★★★★☆

“Each of the pictures had a difference in variety differentiating themselves from others. Different races of pop singers, hair colors, crowd present in some, and indoor/outdoor stage venue.”

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1female pop star performing on a stage, Black woman singer, curly black hair, gold outfit, shining spotlight, microphone, energetic dancing, vibrant stage lights.

2female pop star performing on a stage, White woman singer, long blonde hair, pink sequined dress, singing into mic, blue spotlights, dramatic clouds in background.

3female pop star performing on a stage, Asian woman singer, short red hair, futuristic silver suit, huge indoor arena stage, lasers, pyrotechnics, flying camera angle.

4female pop star performing on a stage, Latina woman singer, long brown wavy hair, colorful floral dress, outdoor night concert venue, massive cheering crowd, fireworks.

Participant 10 · Sep 25, 09:51

Children playing on the equipment at the playground

Prompt changed

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Participant 10 · Sep 25, 09:52

Children playing on the equipment at the playground. The full playground should be visible

Prompt changed

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis. The participant revised the prompt; it was: “Children playing on the equipment at the playground”.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Participant 10 · Sep 25, 09:53

on overhead shot of many children playing on the equipment at the playground. The full playground should be visible

Prompt changed

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis. The participant revised the prompt; it was: “Children playing on the equipment at the playground. The full playground should be visible”.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Participant 10 · Sep 25, 09:54

an overhead shot of many children playing on the equipment at the playground. The full playground should be visible

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis. The participant revised the prompt; it was: “on overhead shot of many children playing on the equipment at the playground. The full playground should be visible”.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1

time of day

3 words

new set · diversity 1.00

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1an overhead shot of many children playing on the equipment at the playground. The full playground should be visible. Many happy kids sliding, swinging, climbing, colorful playground equipment, sand, slides, swings, judo gear, soccer balls.

2an overhead shot of many children playing on the equipment at the playground. The full playground should be visible. Evening time, sunset sky, orange and purple hues, kids playing, parents watching, lights turning on at the park.

3an overhead shot of many children playing on the equipment at the playground. The full playground should be visible. Night time, moonlight, stars, kids with flashlights playing, illuminated playground equipment, festive atmosphere.

4an overhead shot of many children playing on the equipment at the playground. The full playground should be visible. Morning sunrise, bright blue sky, kids in school uniforms running, teachers nearby, colorful flowers, birds.

Round 2

number of seperate pieces of playground equipment

7 words

new set · diversity 1.00

round 2 image 1round 2 image 2round 2 image 3round 2 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1an overhead shot of many children playing on the equipment at the playground. The full playground should be visible. Many happy diverse kids running, swinging, laughing, colorful clothes, bright sunny day, grass, trees, parents watching.

2an overhead shot of many children playing on the equipment at the playground. The full playground should be visible. Single large playground structure with slide, jungle gym, merry-go-round, climbing walls, many kids playing on it.

3an overhead shot of many children playing on the equipment at the playground. The full playground should be visible. Many separate pieces of equipment: individual swings, separate slides, small tunnels, benches, sandpit, picnic tables.

4an overhead shot of many children playing on the equipment at the playground. The full playground should be visible. Four distinct colored play zones, staircase towers, rope bridges, vertical poles, last kids running across open field.

Round 4 Accepted

number of slides visible

4 words

edited the previous set · diversity 1.00

varied ★★★★★ matched ★★★★★

“These are quite good, im happy that is also provided the slides in different configurations and styles instead of just choosing a default. When using the tool itself, changing my prompt did not generate new images even though it ran the generation until i asked for a variation, despite the changed prompt being quite different.”

round 4 image 1round 4 image 2round 4 image 3round 4 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1an overhead shot of many children playing on the equipment at the playground. The full playground should be visible add a large red slide with multiple lanes on the right side.

2an overhead shot of many children playing on the equipment at the playground. The full playground should be visible add a winding yellow spiral slide in the center and a small car slide in the background, with a few kids using them.

3an overhead shot of many children playing on the equipment at the playground. The full playground should be visible add a set of colorful twisting slides and water park elements in the foreground.

4an overhead shot of many children playing on the equipment at the playground. The full playground should be visible add two small playhouse slides with green roofs on the left and a standard yellow slide on the right.

Participant 11 · Sep 25, 09:53

a train departing from a train station as a plane is ascending in the distance

Prompt changed

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Participant 11 · Sep 25, 09:57

a train departing from a train station as a plane is ascending in the distance, side angle

Prompt changed

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis. The participant revised the prompt; it was: “a train departing from a train station as a plane is ascending in the distance”.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Participant 11 · Sep 25, 09:57

a train departing from a train station as a plane is ascending in the distance, side angle, impressionist art style

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis. The participant revised the prompt; it was: “a train departing from a train station as a plane is ascending in the distance, side angle”.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1

time of day, amount of people, number of train cars, class of train car, weather

15 words

new set · diversity 0.56

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1a train departing from a train station as a plane is ascending in the distance, side angle, impressionist art style, bright sunny morning, station empty, single vintage red train car, first class carriage, clear blue sky

2a train departing from a train station as a plane is ascending in the distance, side angle, impressionist art style, twilight dusk, crowd of people waiting, long yellow locomotive with many cars, sleeper class, stars appearing

3a train departing from a train station as a plane is ascending in the distance, side angle, impressionist art style, rainy afternoon, few commuters with umbrellas, heavy green freight train, cargo class, stormy gray clouds

4a train departing from a train station as a plane is ascending in the distance, side angle, impressionist art style, golden hour sunset, busy platform, long blue passenger train, business class lounge, warm glowing lights

Round 2 Accepted

time of day, amount of people, number of train cars, class of train car, weather

15 words

new set · diversity 0.89

varied ★★★☆☆ matched ★★★★☆

“There is a great deal of variation in the pictures, but not as much as I hoped. I do like some of the variation being shown with the nighttime picture and the raining picture. The difference in trains is pretty good too. The variety in people present is very variety with one station having no people, and others have a few, and one has many.”

round 2 image 1round 2 image 2round 2 image 3round 2 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1a train departing from a train station as a plane is ascending in the distance, side angle, impressionist art style. Night time, moonlight, stars, dark blue sky, silhouettes of passengers on the platform, moody lights, vibrant colors.

2a train departing from a train station as a plane is ascending in the distance, side angle, impressionist art style. Bright sunny daytime, clear blue sky, many happy people waving on the platform, colorful clothing, flowers.

3a train departing from a train station as a plane is ascending in the distance, side angle, impressionist art style. A long train with five connected carriages, freight cars mixed with passenger cars, steam engines, industrial details.

4a train departing from a train station as a plane is ascending in the distance, side angle, impressionist art style. Luxury golden first-class train carriages, elegant passengers inside looking out, rain falling gently, umbrellas, soft pastel tones.

Participant 10 · Sep 25, 09:59

Two steampunk robots are attacking the viewer of this image, directly swiping and punching towards the foreground.

Prompt changed

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1

Varying limbs should be broken, showing various states of disrepair

10 words

new set · diversity 1.00

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1Two steampunk robots are attacking the viewer of this image, directly swiping and punching towards the foreground. Aggressive pose, sharp metallic claws, intense eyes, gears, steam, fire, dynamic action, steampunk aesthetic, dark background.

2Two steampunk robots are attacking the viewer, swiping and punching forward. Both robots fully intact, perfect condition, shiny gold and copper plating, intricate gears, cannons, lasers, angry expressions, dramatic motion.

3Two steampunk robots attacking the viewer, swiping and punching. One robot heavily broken: missing arm, exposed wires, broken leg, cracked body. Other robot intact, fighting alongside, steam, sparks, danger.

4Two steampunk robots attacking viewer, punching and swiping. Both robots damaged: one missing head with antenna wires, one with broken wings/mechanical arms,油菜 patches, oil leaks, rust, fierce combat stance.

Participant 10 · Sep 25, 10:03

Two steampunk robots with exposed clockwork internals are attacking the viewer of this image, directly swiping and punching towards the foreground.

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis. The participant revised the prompt; it was: “Two steampunk robots are attacking the viewer of this image, directly swiping and punching towards the foreground.”.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1

type of metal each robot is made out of

9 words

new set · diversity 1.00

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1Two steampunk robots with exposed clockwork internals are attacking the viewer of this image, directly swiping and punching towards the foreground. The robots are entire cast of shiny, polished silver and white metal, gold accents, looking fierce and deadly.

2Two steampunk robots with exposed clockwork internals are attacking the viewer, swiping and punching forward. One robot is made of dark iron and black steel with gears, the other is vibrant copper and bronze with orange lighting, sparks flying.

3Two steampunk robots with exposed clockwork internals attacking the viewer, swiping and punching. Robots made of colorful painted metal, rainbow hues, plastique and aluminum, withversed exams, wires, neon lights, intense action pose.

4Two steampunk robots with exposed clockwork internals are attacking the viewer, swiping and punching. Robots constructed from heavy brass, riveted yellow gold chains, leather straps, gauges, beauty, complex mechanical faces, fierce expression.

Round 2

type of metal each robot is made out of

9 words

new set · diversity 1.00

round 2 image 1round 2 image 2round 2 image 3round 2 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1Two steampunk robots with exposed clockwork internals are attacking the viewer of this image, directly swiping and punching towards the foreground. violent action, fierce expressions, gears, pipes, flames, smoke, dynamic pose.

2Two steampunk robots with exposed clockwork internals are attacking the viewer, swiping and punching forward. Left robot: Polished gold, brass, copper, ornate, royal style. Right robot: Dark steel, silver, sharp edges.

3Two steampunk robots with exposed clockwork internals attacking the viewer, swiping and punching. Both robots: Rustic iron, dark grey metal, heavy plates, nail reinforcement, guarded look, gears visible.

4Two steampunk robots with exposed clockwork internals are attacking the viewer, swiping and punching. One robot: Bright cyan électrique metal, neon lights. Other robot: Red and orange alloy, fiery design.

Round 3 Accepted

type and color of metal each robot is made out of

11 words

edited the previous set · diversity 1.00

varied ★★★★☆ matched ★★★★☆

“It was surprisingly hard to get the images to be diverse using metal alone and i had to add a color modifier because it chose very similar metals”

round 3 image 1round 3 image 2round 3 image 3round 3 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1Two steampunk robots with exposed clockwork internals are attacking the viewer of this image, directly swiping and punching towards the foreground. Add vibrant purple andpNext pink metallic plating and decorations.

2Two steampunk robots with exposed clockwork internals are attacking the viewer of this image, directly swiping and punching towards the foreground. Make one robot made of polished brass and gold, the other of rusted бронze with industrial pipes.

3Two steampunk robots with exposed clockwork internals are attacking the viewer of this image, directly swiping and punching towards the foreground. Cover their bodies with silver armor featuring medieval knight designs and add some Abril wlore elements.

4Two steampunk robots with exposed clockwork internals are attacking the viewer of this image, directly swiping and punching towards the foreground. Color the left robot bright cyan with neon accents, and the right robot red and orange with fiery伙伴们."

Participant 11 · Sep 25, 10:02

an oil painting in the style of American realism or illustrative realism popular of the 20th century, showing a close of a bird in a bird cage with a cat watching it behind.

Prompt changed

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1

bird breed, cat breed, style of living room, time of the day

12 words

new set · diversity 0.67

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1an oil painting in the style of American realism or illustrative realism popular of the 20th century, showing a close of a blue jay in a bird cage with a cat watching it behind. Traditional Victorian living room, heavy wood furniture, daylight streaming through lace curtains.

2an oil painting in the style of American realism or illustrative realism popular of the 20th century, showing a close of a parrot in a bird cage with a cat watching it behind. Modern sleek living room, leather sofa, city view window, evening twilight outside.

3an oil painting in the style of American realism or illustrative realism popular of the 20th century, showing a close of a fluffy white cat and a tropical bird in a cage. Cozy cabin living room, fireplace, warm lamplight, snowy night outside, cat breed Maine Coon.

4an oil painting in the style of American realism or illustrative realism popular of the 20th century, showing a close of a hummingbird in a bird cage with a Siamese cat watching it behind. Bright yellow Moroccan style living room, cushions, potted plants, morning sun.

Round 2

bird breed, cat breed, style of living room, time of the day

12 words

new set · diversity 0.56

round 2 image 1round 2 image 2round 2 image 3round 2 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1an oil painting in the style of American realism or illustrative realism popular of the 20th century, showing a close of a blue jay in a bird cage with a tabby cat watching it behind. Cozy 1950s suburban living room, afternoon sunlight streaming through lace curtains, warm tones.

2an oil painting in the style of American realism or illustrative realism popular of the 20th century, showing a close of a hummingbird in a glass bird cage with a sleek black Persian cat watching it behind. Minimalist modern living room, midnight blue walls, moonlight illuminating the scene.

3an oil painting in the style of American realism or illustrative realism popular of the 20th century, showing a close of a parrot in a rustic wire bird cage with a fluffy Siamese cat watching it behind. Luxurious Art Deco living room, gold accents, rich velvet curtains, evening firelight glow.

4an oil painting in the style of American realism or illustrative realism popular of the 20th century, showing a close of an owl in a vintage wooden bird cage with an orange tabby cat watching it behind. Bohemian eclectic living room, plants and tapestries, soft morning light filtering through sheer curtains.

Participant 11 · Sep 25, 10:10

an oil painting with visible brush strokes in the style of American realism of the 20th century, showing a close of a bird in a bird cage with a cat watching it behind.

Prompt changed

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis. The participant revised the prompt; it was: “an oil painting in the style of American realism or illustrative realism popular of the 20th century, showing a close of a bird in a bird cage with a cat watching it behind.”.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1

bird breed, cat breed, style of living room, time of the day

12 words

new set · diversity 0.56

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1an oil painting with visible brush strokes in the style of American realism of the 20th century, showing a close of a small blue jay in a bird cage with a ginger tabby cat watching it behind, set in a vintage rustic cabin living room at sunset.

2an oil painting with visible brush strokes in the style of American realism of the 20th century, showing a close of a large colorful parrot in a bird cage with a fluffy Persian cat watching it behind, set in a modern minimalist living room at midday sun.

3an oil painting with visible brush strokes in the style of American realism of the 20th century, showing a close of a pigeon in a bird cage with a sleek Siamese cat watching it behind, set in a lavish Art Deco living room at night with city lights.

4an oil painting with visible brush strokes in the style of American realism of the 20th century, showing a close of a robin in a bird cage with a playful Maine Coon cat watching it behind, set in a cozy cottage living room during early morning dawn.

Participant 11 · Sep 25, 10:11

an oil painting with visible brush strokes in the style of American realism of the 20th century, showing a close of a bird in a bird cage with a cat stalking it in the distance.

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis. The participant revised the prompt; it was: “an oil painting with visible brush strokes in the style of American realism of the 20th century, showing a close of a bird in a bird cage with a cat watching it behind.”.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Accepted

bird breed, cat breed, style of living room, time of the day

12 words

new set · diversity 0.56

varied ★★★★☆ matched ★★★☆☆

“All the pictures contain different breeds of cats and birds, different settings and times of day. I like the variety that it generated.”

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1an oil painting with visible brush strokes in the style of American realism of the 20th century, showing a close of a blue jay in a bird cage with a cat stalking it in the distance, set in a minimalist modern living room, late afternoon sun.

2an oil painting with visible brush strokes in the style of American realism of the 20th century, showing a close of a golden finch in a bird cage with a Persian cat stalking it in the distance, set in a cozy Victorian living room filled with rugs, late night.

3an oil painting with visible brush strokes in the style of American realism of the 20th century, showing a close of a colorful parrot in a bird cage with a Maine Coon cat stalking it in the distance, set in an upscale Hollywood-style living room, bright morning.

4an oil painting with visible brush strokes in the style of American realism of the 20th century, showing a close of a hummingbird in a bird cage with a Siamese cat stalking it in the distance, set in a rustic farmhouse living room, dusk.

Participant 10 · Sep 25, 10:06

A pizza being served to a hungry family at a restaurant, in the style of a colourful anime

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1

The style of anime

4 words

new set · diversity 1.00

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A pizza being served to a hungry family at a restaurant, in the style of a colourful anime. Cheering family, dad and mom and three kids, joyfully eating sliced pepperoni pizza, warm lamp, happy restaurant interior.

2A pizza being served to a hungry family at a restaurant, in the style of a colourful anime. Serious aviance style, dark background, glowing neon signs, intense eyes, dramatic posing family, chef graduating滋 dinner edition. Aisha我們要.

3A pizza being served to a hungry family at a restaurant, in the style of a colourful anime. Soft past和中国风 anime,pastel colors,cute characters,日向&_parents serving big pizza,flowers,koi fish,dimension gates,magical chefs,angels wings.

4A pizza being served to a hungry family at a restaurant, in the style of a colourful anime赛 ยojeon super high tech cyberpunk anime, robots waiters, LED lights, futuristic family dressed in cool clothes,Energetic eruption.

Round 2 Accepted

the theme of the anime

5 words

new set · diversity 1.00

varied ★★★★☆ matched ★★★★★

“Good variation with the fighting style, magical girl, and medieval style variations, though the first variation is more of a random cartoon than a specific anime style”

round 2 image 1round 2 image 2round 2 image 3round 2 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A pizza being served to a hungry family at a restaurant, in the style of a colourful anime. Happy parents and three excited kids eating pizza, colorful topping, escolar ukulele waiter, vibrant lights, magical atmosphere.

2A pizza being served to a hungry family at a restaurant, in the style of a colourful anime. Serious shonen battle anime style, hoodie結論 characters, dynamic poses, pizza flying, energy effects, dragons, stars, intense eyes.

3A pizza being served to a hungry family at a restaurant, in the style of a colourful anime. Rose-colored gates alternatively softly邪教去 treato(LL Beauty), female anime chef in elegant dress, fairy decorations, stars, moon,(~なéraires pink bows.

4A pizza being served to a hungry family at a restaurant, in the style of a colourful anime. Kyoto ste編號 কো broad rim figure soldiersuttoflowRed Blue gold Section, traditional garments / されば saga統 ~יסמעو styleurons sightし رواسی בעוס Pescherence.

Their questionnaire

Useful to say what varies: ★★★★☆

Slider behaved as expected: ★★★☆☆

Enjoyed the task: ★★★★★

Preferred: Generate new

Uses image generators: Weekly or more

Wanted to vary but could not: There was a request for different broken limbs on a pair of robots and it didn't seem to change the original images at all, let alone provide varied broken limbs. Most other generations seemed to work fairly well.

Other: I'd love to see a version of this that generates multiple sets of varied images based on different temperature settings at the same time so that I could see the differences between the different settings side by side while rating variations. I think this could help get a feel for what the slider is strong at producing and what it isn't needed for, as I generally defaulted to higher temperatures to force variation without an easy to access baseline to directly compare my results to. I think it would be interesting to see how much of an effect it really has overall. Cheers for letting me participate, I'd enjoy helping out with this again some time.

Would do more: Yes

Participant 11 · Sep 25, 10:13

a cartoon image of a dog, cat, mouse, and fish (in a fishbowl) presented side by side

Prompt changed

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Participant 11 · Sep 25, 10:16

a cartoon image of a dog, cat, mouse, and fish (in a fishbowl) presented side by side, in a single contained image

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis. The participant revised the prompt; it was: “a cartoon image of a dog, cat, mouse, and fish (in a fishbowl) presented side by side”.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1

different breeds, clothing, background setting

5 words

new set · diversity 0.33

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1a cartoon image of a dog, cat, mouse, and fish (in a fishbowl) presented side by side, featuring a golden retriever, wearing pajamas, a Persian cat, human-like mouse, and goldfish, in a cozy bedroom.

2a cartoon image of a dog, cat, mouse, and fish (in a fishbowl) presented side by side, featuring a bulldog, winter coat, tabby cat, wizard mouse, and tropical fish, set against a snowy forest background.

3a cartoon image of a dog, cat, mouse, and fish (in a fishbowl) presented side by side, featuring a Pomeranian, superhero cape, Siamese cat, alien mouse, and colorful fish, in a vibrant outer space setting.

4a cartoon image of a dog, cat, mouse, and fish (in a fishbowl) presented side by side, featuring a chihuahua, medieval knight armor, fluffy Maine Coon, farmer mouse, and koi fish, in a rustic countryside farm.

Round 2 Accepted

different breeds, clothing, background setting

5 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.33

varied ★★★★☆ matched ★★★☆☆

“I love how the animals are displayed in different settings and with different clothing. I had to tinker a few times with the edit and the slider, unfortunately sometimes the fish isn't shown.”

round 2 image 1round 2 image 2round 2 image 3round 2 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1change the breeds to a French Bulldog, Persian cat, and hamster, give them medieval knight attire, and set the background to a forest at sunset

2change the breeds to a beagle, a Scottish Fold cat, and a guinea pig, dress them in red superhero capes, and set the background to a comic book city street at night

3change the breeds to a Boston Terrier and a Siamese cat, give them formal business suits and ties, and set the background to a city skyline at dawn

4change the breeds to a Golden Retriever, a tabby cat, and a standard mouse, give them casual pajamas with patterns, and set the background to a cozy bedroom interior

Participant 11 · Sep 25, 10:19

a lone car driving down a long road in the desert, slight aerial shot

Stopped before choosing an axis

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Participant 11 · Sep 25, 10:22

a macro close up of a bug on a flower

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1

type of bug, type of flower

6 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.11

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1change the yellow flower to a purple daisy

2change the dark speckled bug to a large, metallic blue beetle

3change the yellow flower to a white carnation

4change the patterned bug to a fuzzy, orange ant

Round 2 Accepted

type of bug, type of flower

6 words

new set · diversity 0.67

varied ★★★★★ matched ★★★★☆

round 2 image 1round 2 image 2round 2 image 3round 2 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1a macro close up of a bug on a flower: a vivid blue butterfly with orange wings resting on a bright red rose, dew drops, highly detailed petals, nature photography.

2a macro close up of a bug on a flower: a shiny black beetle with metallic green patterns on a large yellow sunflower, golden center, intricate bug details, shallow depth of field.

3a macro close up of a bug on a flower: a delicate pink ladybug with black spots crawling on a purple lavender bloom, soft purple background, morning light, hyper-realistic.

4a macro close up of a bug on a flower: a fuzzy brown bee covered in pollen hovering near a white daisy with yellow center, spring garden, vibrant colors, extreme close-up.

Their questionnaire

Useful to say what varies: ★★★★★

Slider behaved as expected: ★★★☆☆

Enjoyed the task: ★★★★★

Preferred: Both, for different things

Uses image generators: Weekly or more

Wanted to vary but could not: No, the tool was pretty helpful. It took me a few attempts of adjusting the slider to see the impact it had.

Other: I accidently clicked the wrong button when I was doing the prompt on the car in the highway, I was going to attempt it a second time with the same prompt but I didn't want to get penalized for it, I was going to try to change the color of the car, make of the car, weather, time of day. I think I clicked the wrong button and it advanced to the next step. But overall I really enjoyed this task with creating variety from generated images.

Would do more: Yes

Participant 12 · Sep 25, 10:31

a busy underwater scene full of colorful fish, with one menacing shark lurking around and a coral reef.

Left after 4 rounds

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1

fish size, time of day, coral variation, camera angle

9 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.78

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1a busy underwater scene full of colorful fish, with one menacing shark lurking around and a coral reef, add several giant fish and change time of day to sunset

2a busy underwater scene full of colorful fish, with one menacing shark lurking around and a coral reef, change the time of day to dawn with soft pink and purple light

3a busy underwater scene full of colorful fish, with one menacing shark lurking around and a coral reef, add large star-shaped and brain corals with diverse colors

4a busy underwater scene full of colorful fish, with one menacing shark lurking around and a coral reef, change the camera angle to a low-angle shot looking up towards the surface

Round 2

fish size, time of day, coral variation, camera angle

9 words

new set · diversity 0.78

round 2 image 1round 2 image 2round 2 image 3round 2 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1a busy underwater scene full of colorful fish, with one menacing shark lurking around and a coral reef. Tiny, minuscule neon fish swimming near a small metallic shark and small coral.

2a busy underwater scene full of colorful fish, with one menacing shark lurking around and a coral reef. Gigantic massive рыбы and a huge giant shark, sunset lighting, golden hour, deep ocean.

3a busy underwater scene full of colorful fish, with one menacing shark lurking around and a coral reef. Nighttime underwater, bioluminescent blue glow, purple and pink glowing corals, stars above water.

4a busy underwater scene full of colorful fish, with one menacing shark lurking around and a coral reef. Low angle shot looking up from bottom, diverse coral types, tropical fish, dramatic shark eyes.

Round 3

fish size, time of day, coral variation, camera angle

9 words

new set · diversity 0.78

round 3 image 1round 3 image 2round 3 image 3round 3 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1a busy underwater scene full of colorful fish, with one menacing shark lurking around and a coral reef. Tiny miniature fish swimming fast, terrified expressions, dark deep ocean night time, glowing bioluminescent coral.

2a busy underwater scene full of colorful fish, with one menacing shark lurking around and a coral reef. Giant massive purple and gold fish, huge tropical sea lions, bright sunny daytime, vibrant pink and blue polyp corals.

3a busy underwater scene full of colorful fish, with one menacing shark lurking around and a coral reef. Top-down aerial camera angle showing school of fish, shark below, diverse shaped brain and fan corals, noon sunlight.

4a busy underwater scene full of colorful fish, with one menacing shark lurking around and a coral reef. Side profile close-up camera angle, large medium-sized fish, ominous red coral reef, twilight dusk underwater lighting.

Round 4

fish size, time of day, coral variation, camera angle

9 words

new set · diversity 0.78

round 4 image 1round 4 image 2round 4 image 3round 4 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1a busy underwater scene full of colorful fish, with one menacing shark lurking around and a coral reef. Tiny, miniature neon fish swimming energetically, dark midnight deep sea, mysterious shark.

2a busy underwater scene full of colorful fish, with one menacing shark lurking around and a coral reef. Gigantic huge fish like whales and sharks alongside, bright sunny noon sun rays, vibrant reef.

3a busy underwater scene full of colorful fish, with one menacing shark lurking around and a coral reef. Mosquitoes, tiny baby fish, ancient purple and black jagged dangerous coral, shark watching.

4a busy underwater scene full of colorful fish, with one menacing shark lurking around and a coral reef. Wide angle cinematic shot from above surface, golden hour sunset, diverse pink blue orange corals.

Participant 12 · Sep 25, 10:36

a military shooting range with soldiers practicing on paper targets, they appear professional and concentrated. there's one range master making sure safety is maintained

Prompt changed

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1

vary target distance

3 words

new set · diversity 0.44

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1a military shooting range with soldiers practicing on paper targets at very close range, they appear professional and concentrated. there's one range master making sure safety is maintained

2a military shooting range with soldiers practicing on paper targets at medium distance, they appear professional and concentrated. there's one range master making sure safety is maintained

3a military shooting range with soldiers practicing on paper targets at long distance, they appear professional and concentrated. there's one range master making sure safety is maintained

4a military shooting range with soldiers practicing on paper targets at extreme long distance, they appear professional and concentrated. there's one range master making sure safety is maintained

Round 2

type of firearm

3 words

new set · diversity 0.44

round 2 image 1round 2 image 2round 2 image 3round 2 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A military shooting range with soldiers practicing on paper targets, they appear professional and concentrated. They hold rifles. There's one range master making sure safety is maintained.

2A military shooting range with soldiers practicing on paper targets, they appear professional and concentrated. They hold submachine guns. There's one range master making sure safety is maintained.

3A military shooting range with soldiers practicing on paper targets, they appear professional and concentrated. They hold sniper rifles. There's one range master making sure safety is maintained.

4A military shooting range with soldiers practicing on paper targets, they appear professional and concentrated. They hold pistols. There's one range master making sure safety is maintained.

Participant 12 · Sep 25, 10:40

a military shooting range with soldiers practicing on paper targets, they appear professional and concentrated. there's one range master behind them making sure safety is maintained, the targets are at 30 yards

Left after 2 rounds

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis. The participant revised the prompt; it was: “a military shooting range with soldiers practicing on paper targets, they appear professional and concentrated. there's one range master making sure safety is maintained”.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1

vary target distance

3 words

new set · diversity 0.44

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1a military shooting range with soldiers practicing on paper targets, they appear professional and concentrated. there's one range master behind them making sure safety is maintained, the targets are at 5 yards

2a military shooting range with soldiers practicing on paper targets, they appear professional and concentrated. there's one range master behind them making sure safety is maintained, the targets are at 100 yards

3a military shooting range with soldiers practicing on paper targets, they appear professional and concentrated. there's one range master behind them making sure safety is maintained, the targets are at 200 yards

4a military shooting range with soldiers practicing on paper targets, they appear professional and concentrated. there's one range master behind them making sure safety is maintained, the targets are at 500 yards

Round 2

vary target distance

3 words

new set · diversity 0.89

round 2 image 1round 2 image 2round 2 image 3round 2 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1a military shooting range with soldiers practicing on paper targets, they appear professional and concentrated. there's one range master behind them making sure safety is maintained, the targets are at 30 yards, close-up view of soldiers aiming at very near targets at 10 yards.

2a military shooting range with soldiers practicing on paper targets, they appear professional and concentrated. there's one range master behind them making sure safety is maintained, the targets are at 30 yards, long distance targets at 500 yards in the background, soldiers looking focused.

3a military shooting range with soldiers practicing on paper targets, they appear professional and concentrated. there's one range master behind them making sure safety is maintained, the targets are at 30 yards, medium distance targets at 100 yards, soldiers in tactical gear.

4a military shooting range with soldiers practicing on paper targets, they appear professional and concentrated. there's one range master behind them making sure safety is maintained, the targets are at 30 yards, multiple target sets at varying distances from 30 to 200 yards.

Participant 13 · Sep 25, 10:40

John Cena wrestling against Hollywood Hulk Hogan

Prompt changed

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Participant 13 · Sep 25, 10:41

John Cena wrestling against Hollywood Hulk Hogan, one of them is doing a move to the other

Prompt changed

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis. The participant revised the prompt; it was: “John Cena wrestling against Hollywood Hulk Hogan”.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Participant 13 · Sep 25, 10:42

John Cena wrestling against Hollywood Hulk Hogan, one of them is doing a move to the other, they are actively wrestling

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis. The participant revised the prompt; it was: “John Cena wrestling against Hollywood Hulk Hogan, one of them is doing a move to the other”.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1

They need to actually be wrestling and not just staring at the camera.

13 words

new set · diversity 0.78

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1John Cena wrestling against Hollywood Hulk Hogan, one of them is doing a move to the other, they are actively wrestling. Intense face-off, eye contact locked, muscles tense, gripping each other's shoulders, dynamic wrestling stance in a ring.

2John Cena wrestling against Hollywood Hulk Hogan, one of them is doing a move to the other, they are actively wrestling. Cena performing a dramatic elbow drop onto Hogan, dust flying, referee watching closely, action shot.

3John Cena wrestling against Hollywood Hulk Hogan, one of them is doing a move to the other, they are actively wrestling. Hogan lifting Cena high above his head for a thunderous superplex, crowd cheering, sparks flying.

4John Cena wrestling against Hollywood Hulk Hogan, one of them is doing a move to the other, they are actively wrestling. Fast-paced grappling, Cena applying a submission hold to Hogan's leg, both struggling intensely, sweat and drama.

Round 2

They need to actually be wrestling and not just staring at the camera.

13 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.78

round 2 image 1round 2 image 2round 2 image 3round 2 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1Have John Cena apply a suplex to Hulk Hogan in the ring, adding motion blur and dynamic sparks.

2Add a referee and a cheering crowd, have John Cena deliver a punch to Hulk Hogan's face with sweat flying.

3Have Hulk Hogan lift John Cena onto his shoulders in preparation for a throw, with both characters mid-action.

4Show John Cena applying a headlock to Hulk Hogan, with Hulk Hogan looking distressed and struggling to break free.

Round 3 Accepted

They need to better match the real likeness of John Cena and Hollywood Hulk Hogan. All moves should be physically possible.

21 words

new set · diversity 0.78

varied ★★★☆☆ matched ★★★☆☆

“The likenesses weren't good enough, but they're fine for generic wrestlers.”

round 3 image 1round 3 image 2round 3 image 3round 3 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1John Cena wrestling against Hollywood Hulk Hogan, one doing a move to the other, actively wrestling. Realistic faces, exact likeness of John Cena and Hulk Hogan, intense expressions, sweat, arena lights, action shot.

2John Cena wrestling against Hollywood Hulk Hogan, actively wrestling, one doing a chiropractic neck snap move. Hyper-realistic faces, accurate celebrity likenesses, detailed muscles, dramatic arena crowd background.

3John Cena wrestling against Hollywood Hulk Hogan, actively wrestling, Cena performing his signature Attitude Adjustment move on Hogan. Exact facial features, realistic jerseys, dynamic pose, stadium lighting, intense action.

4John Cena wrestling against Hollywood Hulk Hogan, actively wrestling, Hogan delivering a spinebuster to Cena. Perfect real-life likenesses, detailed facial features, sweat, torn trunks, vibrant crowd, energetic atmosphere.

Participant 12 · Sep 25, 10:43

an e-sports event, we see the gaming monitors for both teams on each side.

Prompt changed

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Participant 12 · Sep 25, 10:45

an e-sports event, we see the gaming monitors for both teams on each side, the screens should be opposing each other so the players can't see the rival's screen.

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis. The participant revised the prompt; it was: “an e-sports event, we see the gaming monitors for both teams on each side.”.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1

crowd

1 word

new set · diversity 0.89

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1an e-sports event, we see the gaming monitors for both teams on each side, the screens should be opposing each other so the players can't see the rival's screen. Close-up of intense gamers focusing on their screens, keyboards and mice, trophies, logos, dramatic lighting, cyberpunk style.

2an e-sports event, we see the gaming monitors for both teams on each side, the screens should be opposing each other so the players can't see the rival's screen. Huge excited crowd in background, cheering fans holding banners, flags, phones, diverse audience, night stadium lighting.

3an e-sports event, we see the gaming monitors for both teams on each side, the screens should be opposing each other so the players can't see the rival's screen. Empty arena focused on players, VIP seats, judges, commentators, technical staff, booths, calm atmosphere.

4an e-sports event, we see the gaming monitors for both teams on each side, the screens should be opposing each other so the players can't see the rival's screen. Colorful vibrant crowd, costumed fans, esports dancers, smoke effects, confetti, energetic party vibe, colorful lights.

Round 2 Accepted

lighting

1 word

new set · diversity 0.89

varied ★★★★☆ matched ★★★☆☆

round 2 image 1round 2 image 2round 2 image 3round 2 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1an e-sports event, we see the gaming monitors for both teams on each side, the screens should be opposing each other so the players can't see the rival's screen. Bright, dramatic stage lighting, colorful neon spotlights, flashing RGB lights, energetic crowd, intense atmosphere.

2an e-sports event, we see the gaming monitors for both teams on each side, the screens should be opposing each other so the players can't see the rival's screen. Dark, moody, low-key lighting, focused spotlights on player hands and keyboards, shadows, serious concentration.

3an e-sports event, we see the gaming monitors for both teams on each side, the screens should be opposing each other so the players can't see the rival's screen. Warm golden sunset lighting, orange and yellow tones, cozy studio vibe, soft ambient glow.

4an e-sports event, we see the gaming monitors for both teams on each side, the screens should be opposing each other so the players can't see the rival's screen. Cool blue and white icy lighting, futuristic tech aesthetic, glowing panels, clean and sterile look.

Participant 12 · Sep 25, 10:46

an ant colony from within, the ants are gathering resources and stockpiling them for the winter

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Accepted

environment

1 word

new set · diversity 1.00

varied ★★★★☆ matched ★★★★☆

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1an ant colony from within, the ants are gathering resources and stockpiling them for the winter. Close up view of many busy ants, carrying seeds, grains, small orange pumpkins, honey pots, intricate underground tunnels.

2an ant colony from within, the ants are gathering resources and stockpiling them for the winter. Dark cave environment, glowing bioluminescent fungi on walls, rocky textures, ants storing food, winter theme outside visible through cracks.

3an ant colony from within, the ants are gathering resources and stockpiling them for the winter. Colorful vibrant lab setting, scientists in white coats observing ants through glass, microscopes, charts, ants working inside.

4an ant colony from within, the ants are gathering resources and stockpiling them for the winter. Lush spring garden environment inside colony, flowers, butterflies, ants carrying colorful petals, berries, joyful atmosphere.

Participant 13 · Sep 25, 10:46

a dog playing football for a professional team

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Accepted

More variety in the jersey colors

6 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.78

varied ★★★★★ matched ★★★★★

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1a dog playing football for a professional team, wearing a red jersey with white and blue stripes

2a dog playing football for a professional team, wearing a bright yellow and black jersey

3a dog playing football for a professional team, wearing a green and white striped jersey

4a dog playing football for a professional team, wearing a purple and gold jersey

Participant 13 · Sep 25, 10:48

show a fat man eating cheeseburgers

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1

Different variety of shirts and shirtless and vary the appearance of the burger

13 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.78

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1show a fat man eating cheeseburgers wearing a vibrant red patterned Hawaiian shirt.

2show a fat man eating cheeseburgers wearing a white button-up dress shirt with a tie.

3show a fat man eating cheeseburgers shirtless with a necklace.

4show a fat man eating a large cheeseburger with bacon and pineapple on top.

Round 2 Accepted

Different races and make the person fatter

7 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.78

varied ★★★★☆ matched ★★★★☆

round 2 image 1round 2 image 2round 2 image 3round 2 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1change the man's race to white and make him significantly fatter

2change the man's race to black and make him very overweight

3change the man's race to Hispanic and make him moderately fat

4make the man extremely obese and Asian

Participant 12 · Sep 25, 10:48

a collection of vintage games and consoles

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Accepted

more consoles

2 words

new set · diversity 0.67

varied ★★★★★ matched ★★★★★

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1a collection of vintage games and consoles, mostly classic handheld game boys, nintendogs, and original red gaming cartridges, nostalgic display.

2a collection of vintage games and consoles, featuring a large array of powerful home consoles like PlayStation 1, 2, Saturn, and Dreamcast with controllers.

3a collection of vintage games and consoles, focusing on futuristic retro consoles, arcade cabinets, and colorful gaming station setups from the 80s and 90s.

4a collection of vintage games and consoles, displayed on shelves with rare limited edition consoles, boxed versions, rarity tags, and luxury gaming memorabilia.

Their questionnaire

Useful to say what varies: ★★★★★

Slider behaved as expected: ★★★★☆

Enjoyed the task: ★★★★★

Preferred: Both, for different things

Uses image generators: Weekly or more

Wanted to vary but could not: Not that I can think of at this moment but it appears to not pick up the implicit intent as well as it does with the explicit intent of the user

Would do more: Yes

Participant 13 · Sep 25, 10:51

show me a snail wearing shoes

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Accepted

Different shoe types and number of shoes

7 words

new set · diversity 0.78

varied ★★★★★ matched ★★★★★

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1show me a snail wearing shoes. The snail is cute and colorful, wearing a single classic black leather dress shoe on its foot, crawling on grass.

2show me a snail wearing shoes. The snail has four tiny shoes on all its legs, different styles like sandals, boots, sneakers, and flip-flops, vibrant colors.

3show me a snail wearing shoes. The snail is wearing a pair of bright red high-heeled stilettos and a fancy bow tie, elegant pose on a flower.

4show me a snail wearing shoes. The snail is wearing two huge oversized basketball shoes with colorful laces, straps, and logos, looking playful and athletic.

Participant 13 · Sep 25, 10:52

a pilot flying and also going to the bathroom

Prompt changed

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Participant 13 · Sep 25, 10:53

a pilot flying and also going to the bathroom, pilot sitting on a toilet, not feeling good

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis. The participant revised the prompt; it was: “a pilot flying and also going to the bathroom”.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Accepted

Pilot is sitting on a toilet and not feeling good

10 words

new set · diversity 0.78

varied ★★★★★ matched ★★★★★

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1a pilot flying and also going to the bathroom, pilot sitting on a toilet, not feeling good, pilot wearing a crisp white uniform and blue tie, looking pale and sweaty inside a private jet lavatory.

2a pilot flying and also going to the bathroom, pilot sitting on a toilet, not feeling good, elderly female pilot in brown uniform, holding stomach, distressed expression, medical kit nearby in cockpit background.

3a pilot flying and also going to the bathroom, pilot sitting on a toilet, not feeling good, young male pilot in flight suit, vomiting slightly, emergency crew hovering outside door, urgent atmosphere.

4a pilot flying and also going to the bathroom, pilot sitting on a toilet, not feeling good, pilot wearing sunglasses and cap, dark mood, high-tech futuristic toilet, holographic displays showing health stats failing.

Their questionnaire

Useful to say what varies: ★★★★☆

Slider behaved as expected: ★★★★☆

Enjoyed the task: ★★★★★

Preferred: Both, for different things

Uses image generators: A few times

Wanted to vary but could not: n/a

Would do more: Yes

Participant 14 · Sep 25, 11:06

A scholar stickman reading a massive, ancient book by candlelight in a dusty library.

Prompt changed

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1

A scholar stickman reading a massive, ancient book by candlelight in a dusty library, I want a different library setting in each picture

23 words

new set · diversity 0.33

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A scholar stickman reading a massive, ancient book by candlelight in a dusty, submerged underwater library with fish swimming around.

2A scholar stickman reading a massive, ancient book by candlelight in a dusty, futuristic space station library filled with floating holographic archives.

3A scholar stickman reading a massive, ancient book by candlelight in a dusty, high-noon sunlit desert nomad tent library scattered with sand.

4A scholar stickman reading a massive, ancient book by candlelight in a dusty, towering vertical skyscraper library with endless glass stairs.

Round 2

A scholar stickman reading a massive, ancient book by candlelight in a dusty library, I want a different library setting in each picture

23 words

new set · diversity 0.33

round 2 image 1round 2 image 2round 2 image 3round 2 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A scholar stickman reading a massive, ancient book by candlelight in a dusty, submerged underwater library with fish swimming around.

2A scholar stickman reading a massive, ancient book by candlelight in a dusty, futuristic space station library filled with floating holographic archives.

3A scholar stickman reading a massive, ancient book by candlelight in a dusty, high-noon sunlit desert nomad tent library scattered with sand.

4A scholar stickman reading a massive, ancient book by candlelight in a dusty, towering vertical skyscraper library with glass elevators and neon lights.

Participant 14 · Sep 25, 11:14

A scholar 2D stickman reading a massive, ancient book by candlelight in a dusty library.

Not what they wanted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis. The participant revised the prompt; it was: “A scholar stickman reading a massive, ancient book by candlelight in a dusty library.”.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Rejected

color scheme

2 words

new set · diversity 0.33

varied ★★☆☆☆ matched ★☆☆☆☆

“I wanted a stickman in the image, but these are real human like characters. It did not change the color scheme”

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A scholar 2D stickman reading a massive, ancient book by candlelight in a dusty library, monochromatic black and white style.

2A scholar 2D stickman reading a massive, ancient book by candlelight in a dusty library, vibrant neon green and purple color scheme.

3A scholar 2D stickman reading a massive, ancient book by candlelight in a dusty library, warm golden and deep orange hues.

4A scholar 2D stickman reading a massive, ancient book by candlelight in a dusty library, cool icy blue and shimmering silver tones.

Participant 15 · Sep 25, 11:10

A street musician performing in a busy city square

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Accepted

Musician's clothing style

3 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.67

varied ★★★★★ matched ★★★★★

“THe clothing changed clearly while the musician, guitar and city setting stayed consistent.”

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1change the musician's clothing to a colorful, patterned folk outfit with a vest and scarf.

2change the musician's clothing to a sharp, modern black suit with a tie and wingtip shoes.

3add a wide-brimmed hat, denim jacket, and boots to the musician's outfit.

4change the musician's clothing to a stylish 1940s era trench coat and fedora.

Participant 14 · Sep 25, 11:17

A minimalist monk meditating on top of a jagged mountain peak during a storm.

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Accepted

Use different daytime in every picture like sunrise, pitch-black night, red-blood sunset and an cloudy afternoon

16 words

new set · diversity 0.67

varied ★★★★★ matched ★★★★★

“Followed my instructions properly. Gave me four different images in 4 different times.”

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A minimalist monk meditating on top of a jagged mountain peak during a storm. Early sunrise, golden light breaking through dark storm clouds, calm water below, serene expression.

2A minimalist monk meditating on top of a jagged mountain peak during a storm. Pitch-black night, full moon and lightning illuminating the monk, stars, snow-covered jagged rocks.

3A minimalist monk meditating on top of a jagged mountain peak during a storm. Dramatic red-blood sunset, fiery orange sky, storm clouds swirling, rain, silhouetted monk.

4A minimalist monk meditating on top of a jagged mountain peak during a storm. Cloudy afternoon, gray overcast sky, soft diffused light, wet rocks, rain falling, peaceful meditation.

Participant 15 · Sep 25, 11:19

A family having a picnic in a sunny park

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Accepted

weather conditions

2 words

new set · diversity 0.67

varied ★★★★★ matched ★★★★★

“The weather changed clearly from sunny to rainy, snowy and cloudy.”

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A family having a picnic in a sunny park. Bright sunshine, clear blue sky, green trees, happy family eating sandwiches, colorful blankets, laughter, vibrant summer day.

2A family having a picnic in a sunny park. Heavy rainstorm, umbrellas open, wet ground, family laughing under shelter, colorful raincoats, dynamic raindrops, dramatic sky.

3A family having a picnic in a sunny park. Snowy winter day, family in warm coats having picnic, snow covering grass, hot chocolate, festive atmosphere, bright sun through snow.

4A family having a picnic in a sunny park. Overcast gloomy morning, grey clouds, family with picnic basket, slight drizzle, cozy mood, soft lighting, autumn leaves on ground.

Participant 15 · Sep 25, 11:23

A cyclist riding along a mountain road

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1

Time of day

3 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.67

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A cyclist riding along a mountain road, change the time of day to sunrise with soft pink and orange sky and long shadows.

2A cyclist riding along a mountain road, change the time of day to midday with bright overhead sunlight and minimal shadows.

3A cyclist riding along a mountain road, change the time of day to dusk with a golden hour glow and warm ambient light.

4A cyclist riding along a mountain road, change the time of day to nighttime with artificial streetlights illuminating the road and the cyclist.

Round 2 Accepted

time of day, cyclist helmet and t shirt color

9 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.67

varied ★★★★★ matched ★★★★★

round 2 image 1round 2 image 2round 2 image 3round 2 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A cyclist riding along a mountain road, change the time of day to sunrise and the helmet and t shirt to yellow and white

2A cyclist riding along a mountain road, change the time of day to midday and the helmet and t shirt to blue and red

3A cyclist riding along a mountain road, change the time of day to sunset and the helmet and t shirt to orange and black

4A cyclist riding along a mountain road, change the time of day to night and the helmet and t shirt to neon green and purple

Participant 14 · Sep 25, 11:24

A detective looking through a magnifying glass at a glowing footprint on the floor.

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1

I want a different crime scene in each picture like a jazz club, high-tech lab, a hotel, an office

19 words

new set · diversity 0.89

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A detective looking through a magnifying glass at a glowing footprint on the floor. A cozy vintage jazz club background with saxophones, dim lights, jazz musicians, smoke, and an audience watching.

2A detective looking through a magnifying glass at a glowing footprint on the floor. A high-tech laboratory setting with holographic screens, beakers, robots, and advanced machinery surrounding the scene.

3A detective looking through a magnifying glass at a glowing footprint on the floor. Luxury hotel lobby background with elegant chandeliers, marble floors, luggage, waiters, and glamorous guests in the back.

4A detective looking through a magnifying glass at a glowing footprint on the floor. Busy modern office environment with desks, computers, filing cabinets, plants, and colleagues working in the background.

Round 2 Accepted

change the crime scene location to beach, hotel, a road, a home

12 words

new set · diversity 0.89

varied ★★★★★ matched ★★★★★

“Followed my instructions properly, gave me 4 different crime scene locations”

round 2 image 1round 2 image 2round 2 image 3round 2 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A detective looking through a magnifying glass at a glowing footprint on the floor. The scene is a sandy beach at night, with waves, moonlight, seagulls, and a detective in a trench coat.

2A detective looking through a magnifying glass at a glowing footprint on the floor. Luxurious hotel lobby with chandeliers, fancy furniture, guests in background, detective examining a glowing footprint.

3A detective looking through a magnifying glass at a glowing footprint on the floor. Busy city road at night, streetlights, cars, traffic, detective in raincoat investigating a mysterious glowing footprint.

4A detective looking through a magnifying glass at a glowing footprint on the floor. Cozy living room, bookshelves, warm lamp, carpet, detective in suspenders examining a glowing footprint near a sofa.

Participant 15 · Sep 25, 11:26

A family celebrating Diwali outside their home

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Accepted

Make it night and use different lighting style.

8 words

new set · diversity 0.67

varied ★★★★★ matched ★★★★☆

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A family celebrating Diwali outside their home. Nighttime, bright golden fireworks exploding, vivid colorful lamps, happy family smiling, festive decorations, vibrant rangoli on ground.

2A family celebrating Diwali outside their home. Nighttime, soft moonlight and gentle candle glow, intimate warm tones, family holding diyas, quiet serene atmosphere, stars in sky.

3A family celebrating Diwali outside their home. Nighttime, dramatic cinematic neon lights, purple and blue hues, futuristic lanterns, family in traditional modern clothes, dynamic action poses.

4A family celebrating Diwali outside their home. Nighttime, black and white high contrast style with selective red accent on oil lamps, moody shadows, elegant vintage photography vibe.

Participant 15 · Sep 25, 11:30

A street food vendor preparing dosa at a busy Indian market

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Accepted

Vendor's clothing style.

3 words

edited the previous set · diversity 1.00

varied ★★★★★ matched ★★★★☆

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A street food vendor preparing dosa at a busy Indian market wearing a colorful traditional Indian kurta and turban

2A street food vendor preparing dosa at a busy Indian market wearing a modern Western outfit with a cap and jeans

3A street food vendor preparing dosa at a busy Indian market wearing a vibrant embroidered shawl and patterned长裤

4A street food vendor preparing dosa at a busy Indian market wearing a clean white chef's uniform with an apron

Their questionnaire

Useful to say what varies: ★★★★★

Slider behaved as expected: ★★★★★

Enjoyed the task: ★★★★★

Preferred: Edit these

Uses image generators: Weekly or more

Wanted to vary but could not: No, I was able to vary the aspects I wanted.

Other: The task was interesting and the image variations were easy to understand.

Would do more: Yes

Participant 14 · Sep 25, 11:31

An astronaut floating outside a spaceship, trying to catch a floating slice of pizza.

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Accepted

show different astronaut reactions like reaching out desperately, saluting the pizza, floating upside down in panic, very happy seeing the pizza slice

22 words

new set · diversity 0.89

varied ★★★★★ matched ★★★★★

“Followed my instructions properly. The astronaut is showing different reactions in picture”

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1An astronaut floating outside a spaceship, trying to catch a floating slice of pizza. The astronaut is reaching out desperately with both hands, eyes wide, struggling against zero gravity, stars in background.

2An astronaut floating outside a spaceship, trying to catch a floating slice of pizza. Astronaut saluting the pizza slice with a helmet visor reflection, smiling proudly, colorful spacesuit, vibrant nebula background.

3An astronaut floating outside a spaceship, trying to catch a floating slice of pizza. Astronaut floating upside down in panic, arms flailing, helmet off showing shocked face, pizza spinning nearby, stars.

4An astronaut floating outside a spaceship, trying to catch a floating slice of pizza. Astronaut looking extremely happy and relieved, giving a thumbs up, hugging the pizza slice, confetti, bright smile, space scene.

Participant 14 · Sep 25, 11:36

A rockstar performing a solo on an electric guitar on a stage in front of a massive crowd.

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Accepted

add these effects in the pictures - laser beams, heavy strobe lights, columns of fire, thick smoke

17 words

new set · diversity 0.89

varied ★★★★★ matched ★★★★★

“Properly followed my suggestions. Gave different lighting effect in each picture”

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A rockstar performing a solo on an electric guitar on a stage in front of a massive crowd. Intense laser beams cutting through the dark air, colorful lights, audience holding phones, energetic concert atmosphere.

2A rockstar performing a solo on an electric guitar on a stage in front of a massive crowd. Heavy flashing strobe lights, vibrant neon colors, dynamic poses, sweat, hair flying, electric guitar solo moment.

3A rockstar performing a solo on an electric guitar on a stage in front of a massive crowd. Two tall columns of roaring fire behind the guitarist, dramatic silhouettes, intense expression, rockstar outfit.

4A rockstar performing a solo on an electric guitar on a stage in front of a massive crowd. Thick dark smoke filling the arena, foggy atmosphere, spotlights on the guitarist, massive fans cheering in background.

Their questionnaire

Useful to say what varies: ★★★★★

Slider behaved as expected: ★★★★★

Enjoyed the task: ★★★★★

Preferred: Both, for different things

Uses image generators: Weekly or more

Wanted to vary but could not: The tool covered most of the variations I needed and was easy to use. A little more flexibility for fine-tuning specific elements would make it even better.

Would do more: Yes

Participant 16 · Sep 25, 11:37

city of Chicago at night in a winter snow storm

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Accepted

less snow falling

3 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.56

varied ★★★★★ matched ★★★★★

“The edited images showed drastically less snow falling in the pictures which cleared up the view of the city from the white pieces falling.”

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1add heavy snowfall and blowing snow in the sky

2remove most of the snow falling, just light flurries

3add light intermittent snow with streaks in the sky

4make it completely snowless, clear night air

Participant 16 · Sep 25, 11:42

inside a beverage bottling plant where cans are being filled with a liquid beverage. workers present, sterile environment.

Prompt changed

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1

less worker presence, uniform beverages being produced

7 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.44

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1Add more workers in the background inspecting the line.

2Keep all workers, but add different colored beverages being poured into cans.

3Remove visible workers from the background and lower the count in the scene.

4Keep the workers, but change the cans to contain only the same single yellow beverage.

Participant 16 · Sep 25, 11:47

inside a beverage bottling plant where cans are being filled with a liquid beverage all uniform in design. minimal workers present, sterile environment

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis. The participant revised the prompt; it was: “inside a beverage bottling plant where cans are being filled with a liquid beverage. workers present, sterile environment.”.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1

all cans should look the same.

6 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.11

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1change the branding on the gold cans to feature a red soft drink label

2keep the gold can branding but add some different, more industrial style text

3change the gold cans to green 7UP style branding

4keep the gold can branding but change the text to be black letters only

Round 2

all cans should look the same.

6 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.78

round 2 image 1round 2 image 2round 2 image 3round 2 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1inside a beverage bottling plant where cans are being filled with a liquid beverage all uniform in design. minimal workers present, sterile environment. Make all cans have distinct, varied label designs and colors.

2inside a beverage bottling plant where cans are being filled with a liquid beverage all uniform in design. minimal workers present, sterile environment. Ensure all cans have identical red labels with the same logo.

3inside a beverage bottling plant where cans are being filled with a liquid beverage all uniform in design. minimal workers present, sterile environment. Add diverse, colorful seasonal labels to the cans, each showing different fruit flavors.

4inside a beverage bottling plant where cans are being filled with a liquid beverage all uniform in design. minimal workers present, sterile environment. Make all cans green with a single geometric pattern on the label.

Round 8 Accepted

all cans should look the same.

6 words

new set · diversity 0.78

varied ★★★★★ matched ★★★★★

“This newly generated group made all the cans uniform and lessened the presence of the workers in the photos.”

round 8 image 1round 8 image 2round 8 image 3round 8 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1inside a beverage bottling plant where cans are being filled with a liquid beverage all uniform in design. minimal workers present, sterile environment. All cans are identical silver color with red logo, same text, same lid, perfectly matching wrappers, no variation on can design.

2inside a beverage bottling plant where cans are being filled with a liquid beverage all uniform in design. minimal workers present, sterile environment. All cans look exactly the same blue color, same label layout, same font, identical graphics, mass production line focus.

3inside a beverage bottling plant where cans are being filled with a liquid beverage all uniform in design. minimal workers present, sterile environment. Close up of single aluminum can being filled, no label yet, plain metal texture, uniform shape, sterile background.

4inside a beverage bottling plant where cans are being filled with a liquid beverage all uniform in design. minimal workers present, sterile environment._rows of finished cans, all identical gold color, same star logo on front, same barcode side, perfect symmetry and uniformity.

Participant 17 · Sep 25, 11:49

A stylish outdoor balcony

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Accepted

furniture layout

2 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.44

varied ★★★★☆ matched ★★★★☆

“They varied the right thing, but the size of the balcony doesn't really fit my prompt of "long but slightly narrow"”

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1Add a large dining table and two chairs opposite the sofa to create a social eating space.

2Arrange the furniture in a straight line against the back wall to maximize open floor space.

3Move the furniture to one corner and add a hanging chair to create a relaxing reading nook.

4Arrange the furniture facing inward in a circular layout to encourage conversation.

Participant 16 · Sep 25, 11:53

a ballet performance, view from the audience with 4 female dancers and 1 male dancer. try the nutcracker theme.

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1

only 4 female dancers with the male dancer in the center of them

13 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.22

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1Moving the male dancer to the center with the four female dancers surrounding him on the stage.

2Cancel the male's surrounding pose and arrange the four female dancers in a line behind him.

3Moving the four female dancers in front of the male dancer and moving the male behind them.

4Moving the male dancer to the side edge of the stage with the four female dancers watching him from the center of the stage.

Round 2

only 4 female dancers with the male dancer in the center of them

13 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.78

round 2 image 1round 2 image 2round 2 image 3round 2 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1add a male dancer in the center of the four female dancers, with his arms raised.

2add a male dancer standing behind the central female dancer, holding her hand.

3move the male dancer to the center front, flanked by the four female dancers in a semicircle.

4place the male dancer on the right side of the stage, watching the four female dancers.

Round 3 Accepted

only 4 female dancers with the male dancer in the center of them

13 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.44

varied ★★★☆☆ matched ★★★☆☆

“I could not get the model to only place 4 female dancers and 1 male dancer on the stage. There was always at least one photo with 3 or 5 female dancers. I tried different variations of variance to no success.”

round 3 image 1round 3 image 2round 3 image 3round 3 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1Arrage the 5 dancers in a horizontal line with the male dancer positioned exactly in the center holding hands with the dancers next to him.

2Move the male dancer to the background behind the 4 female dancers, placing the women in a straight line across the front.

3Form a semi-circle of the 4 female dancers around the male dancer, who stands at the focal point of the circle.

4Place the male dancer to the right stage edge while the 4 female dancers stand in a line to his left.

Participant 17 · Sep 25, 11:54

A cute picnic date

Prompt changed

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1

setting, time of day, framing (close up of picnic spread vs shot of couple etc)

15 words

new set · diversity 0.78

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A cute picnic date. Close-up shot of the picnic spread: cute baskets, colorful foods, flowers, blankets, sunflowers, cute jars, bottles, and happy couple hands holding.

2A cute picnic date. Evening time, sunset sky. A cute couple sitting on grass, sharing food, laughing, holding hands, romantic atmosphere, stars appearing, lanterns.

3A cute picnic date. Wide shot showing diverse setting: a beautiful beach with ocean waves, palm trees, clear blue sky, cute couple picnicking happily on sand.

4A cute picnic date. Cozy forest setting at noon. Sunlight through trees. Cute couple in casual clothes eating cake, drinking juice, surrounded by mushrooms and greenery.

Participant 17 · Sep 25, 11:57

A cute picnic date, photo realistic

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis. The participant revised the prompt; it was: “A cute picnic date”.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1

setting, time of day, framing (close up of picnic spread vs shot of couple etc)

15 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.78

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1Add a city skyline with sunset lights in the background and add more food items to the foreground.

2Change the scene to add a wooden deck and a Wi-Fi connection in a modern garden setting.

3Zoom in on the picnic spread, showing close-up of plates with quiche, fruit, and utensils, cropping out the couple's faces.

4Add two children and a dog playing nearby, and change the time of day to a bright sunny morning with balloons.

Round 2 Accepted

setting, time of day, framing (close up of picnic spread vs shot of couple etc)

15 words

new set · diversity 0.33

varied ★★★☆☆ matched ★★★★★

“They varied some of the things I asked like the setting and time of day, but they didnt vary the framing of the picture like I requested”

round 2 image 1round 2 image 2round 2 image 3round 2 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A cute picnic date, photo realistic, sunny afternoon park, close up of picnic spread with baskets and foods

2A cute picnic date, photo realistic, twilight by a lake, wide shot of happy couple enjoying food together

3A cute picnic date, photo realistic, rainy garden setting, medium shot of well-dressed couple sharing a blanket

4A cute picnic date, photo realistic, moonlit rooftop, overhead framing of blanket with two people laughing softly

Participant 16 · Sep 25, 11:58

show a busy neighborhood gym at rush hour in the late afternoon. Machines are mostly full being used, squat racks are busy, sweat and towels are present. keep the people present under 10. mirrors on walls ok to add space.

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1

vary the male to female ratio more. keep it under 10 people in the photo. more colorful shirts.

18 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.89

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1show a busy neighborhood gym at rush hour in the late afternoon. Machines are mostly full being used, squat racks are busy, sweat and towels are present. keep the people present under 10. Add more female gym-goers wearing colorful shirts and leggings, aiming for a female-to-male ratio of about 70-30. mirrors on walls ok to add space.

2show a busy neighborhood gym at rush hour in the late afternoon. Machines are mostly full being used, squat racks are busy, sweat and towels are present. keep the people present under 10. Add several men in bright, colorful graphic t-shirts lifting weights. mirrors on walls ok to add space.

3show a busy neighborhood gym at rush hour in the late afternoon. Machines are mostly full being used, squat racks are busy, sweat and towels are present. keep the people present under 10. Add a diverse group of women as the main focus, wearing vibrant workout gear, with a couple of men in the background. mirrors on walls ok to add space.

4show a busy neighborhood gym at rush hour in the late afternoon. Machines are mostly full being used, squat racks are busy, sweat and towels are present. keep the people present under 10. Add a few men and women in bold, neon-colored athletic wear working out together. mirrors on walls ok to add space.

Round 2 Accepted

vary the male to female ratio more. keep it under 10 people in the photo. more colorful shirts.

18 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.44

varied ★★★★☆ matched ★★★★☆

“The edits worked very well and followed the instructions with adding more color and varying the male to female ratio.”

round 2 image 1round 2 image 2round 2 image 3round 2 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1Add more female gym-goers in pink, purple, and green shirts to the scene.

2Change the majority of the people to muscular men wearing colorful graphic tees and tank tops.

3Replace most people with women in bright neon workout gear like yellow, orange, and teal.

4Adjust the population to an equal 50/50 ratio of men and women mixing their outfits.

Participant 17 · Sep 25, 12:00

a black and white photo strip taken in a photo booth of two girl friends having fun

Prompt changed

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Participant 17 · Sep 25, 12:03

a black and white photo strip with 4 photos in the strip, taken in a photo booth of two girl friends having fun

Prompt changed

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis. The participant revised the prompt; it was: “a black and white photo strip taken in a photo booth of two girl friends having fun”.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Participant 17 · Sep 25, 12:04

a hand holding up a black and white photo strip (4 photos in one strip) of two girls having fun, taken in a old school photo booth

Not what they wanted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis. The participant revised the prompt; it was: “a black and white photo strip with 4 photos in the strip, taken in a photo booth of two girl friends having fun”.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1

poses of the girls, ethnicity, style (hair, fashion etc)

9 words

new set · diversity 0.44

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1a hand holding up a black and white photo strip (4 photos in one strip) of two girls having fun, taken in a old school photo booth. The girls are standing side-by-side holding maracas, dancing energetically with wild curly hair and floral 1970s dresses.

2a hand holding up a black and white photo strip (4 photos in one strip) of two girls having fun, taken in a old school photo booth. The girls are sitting cross-legged laughing on a beanbag, one with African descent and braids, the other Asian with pigtails wearing denim.

3a hand holding up a black and white photo strip (4 photos in one strip) of two girls having fun, taken in a old school photo booth. The girls making peace signs are kissing on lips, wearing elegant gowns with long flowing hair and pearls.

4a hand holding up a black and white photo strip (4 photos in one strip) of two girls having fun, taken in a old school photo booth. The girls are hugging tightly jumping in the air, one Scandinavian blonde and one Latin girl with voluminous red hair and sporty 80s outfits.

Round 2

poses of the girls, ethnicity, style (hair, fashion etc)

9 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.22

round 2 image 1round 2 image 2round 2 image 3round 2 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1change the poses of the two girls to one of them giving a thumbs-up and the other waving while wearing a short-sleeved white top and black-patterned dress.

2change the poses of the two girls to one sticking her tongue out playfully and the other making a surprised face while wearing a vintage sixties-style floral blouse.

3change the poses of the two girls to one leaning against the other affectionately with heads shoulder-to-shoulder.

4change the poses of the two girls to both dancing enthusiastically with energetic gestures and expressive smiles.

Round 3

poses of the girls in the photo strip, ethnicity of the girls in the photo strip, style of the girls in the photo strip (hair, fashion etc)

27 words

new set · diversity 0.22

round 3 image 1round 3 image 2round 3 image 3round 3 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1a hand holding up a black and white photo strip (4 photos in one strip) of two girls having fun, taken in a old school photo booth: two young Asian girls in pigtails and flower skirts, laughing and jumping together.

2a hand holding up a black and white photo strip (4 photos in one strip) of two girls having fun, taken in a old school photo booth: two diverse ethnic girls, one Black and one Latina, posing with bold red lipsticks and ballet flats.

3a hand holding up a black and white photo strip (4 photos in one strip) of two girls having fun, taken in a old school photo booth: two girls with blonde bobbed hair wearing 1950s polka dot dresses and poodle skirts, spinning wildly.

4a hand holding up a black and white photo strip (4 photos in one strip) of two girls having fun, taken in a old school photo booth: two girls in street style hoodies and sneakers, making silly grimace faces and peace signs.

Round 4

poses of the girls in the photo strip, ethnicity of the girls in the photo strip, style of the girls in the photo strip (hair, fashion etc)

27 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.11

round 4 image 1round 4 image 2round 4 image 3round 4 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1change the poses of the girls from heads-up entertainment to a silhouette against a bright wall

2change the ethnicity of the girls from Anglo-Saxon descent to South Asian descent

3change the style of the girls's clothes from vintage 1950s dresses to edgy modern black t-shirts

4change the poses of the girls from standing side-by-side to a playful interaction with one lying on the floor

Round 5 Rejected

style of the girls in the photo strip (hair, fashion etc)

11 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.11

varied ★★★★☆ matched ★☆☆☆☆

“Varied the right thing but changed things about my prompt like the black and white aspect”

round 5 image 1round 5 image 2round 5 image 3round 5 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1change the girls' fashion to vintage 1920s flapper dresses with feathers

2change the girls' fashion to modern 2000s preppy sweaters and pleated skirts

3change the girls' fashion to hip-hop 90s streetwear with oversized hoodies and cargo pants

4change the girls' fashion to futuristic cyberpunk neon leather jackets and synthetic boots

Participant 16 · Sep 25, 12:07

I'm a kid Christmas morning standing at the top of the staircase catching Santa putting out presents. he doesn't know I'm there and I'm hiding. very decorated living room and comfy feeling.

Prompt changed

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1

Santa is not interacting with child, ignorance of presence of child. child is at top of stairs watching santa

19 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.67

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1In the second image, have the boy silently peek from behind the staircase railing while looking at Santa with surprise. Ensure Santa remains unaware of the boy.

2In the second image, have Santa raise a hand in a friendly wave while smiling broadly, as if acknowledging the child’s presence without direct interaction.

3In the second image, have Santa back away slightly laughing, pretending to suddenly notice the child hiding behind the banister at the top of the stairs.

4In the second image, have Santa completely ignore the child at the top of the stairs, keeping his focus entirely on a stack of gifts he is arranging nearby.

Round 2

Santa is not interacting with child, ignorance of presence of child. child is at top of stairs watching santa

19 words

new set · diversity 0.67

round 2 image 1round 2 image 2round 2 image 3round 2 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1I'm a kid Christmas morning standing at the top of the staircase catching Santa putting out presents. He is busy wrapping a red gift box, completely unaware I am hiding above. Very decorated living room, comfy feeling, Christmas lights.

2I'm a kid Christmas morning standing at the top of the staircase catching Santa putting out presents. He is looking out the snowy window at falling snowflakes, totally ignorant of a child hiding and watching him from above.

3I'm a kid Christmas morning standing at the top of the staircase catching Santa putting out presents. He is laughing with another elf in the living room, ignoring the hidden child at the top of the stairs watching.

4I'm a kid Christmas morning standing at the top of the staircase catching Santa putting out presents. He is stretching to fix a tinsel garland on the wall, oblivious to the surprised kid hiding silently above.

Round 3

Santa is not interacting with child, ignorance of presence of child. child is at top of stairs watching santa

19 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.00

round 3 image 1round 3 image 2round 3 image 3round 3 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1In the second image from the fourth, make Santa look directly at the child and lean in for an excited exchange.

2In the first image from the fourth, make the child hide behind the stairs and whisper excitedly to Santa.

3In the third image from the fourth, make Santa turn his back fully and ignore the child completely.

4In the fourth image from the fourth, make Santa pause to look blindly back at the child halfway up the stairs.

Participant 16 · Sep 25, 12:20

I'm a kid Christmas morning standing at the top of the staircase catching Santa putting out presents. santa doesn't know I'm there and I'm hiding. very decorated living room and comfy feeling.

Not what they wanted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis. The participant revised the prompt; it was: “I'm a kid Christmas morning standing at the top of the staircase catching Santa putting out presents. he doesn't know I'm there and I'm hiding. very decorated living room and comfy feeling.”.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Rejected

Santa is not interacting with child, ignorance of presence of child. child is at top of stairs watching santa

19 words

new set · diversity 0.67

varied ★★☆☆☆ matched ★★☆☆☆

“I could not get Santa to be near the tree separated from the child and have the child watch from the top of the stairs.”

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1I'm a kid Christmas morning standing at the top of the staircase catching Santa putting out presents. Santa doesn't know I'm there and I'm hiding. Very decorated living room and comfy feeling. Close-up of Santa's back as he decorates a tree, child peeking over railing.

2I'm a kid Christmas morning standing at the top of the staircase catching Santa putting out presents. Santa doesn't know I'm there and I'm hiding. Very decorated living room and comfy feeling. Santa is laughing with elves, focused on wrapping gifts, unaware of child watching from stairs.

3I'm a kid Christmas morning standing at the top of the staircase catching Santa putting out presents. Santa doesn't know I'm there and I'm hiding. Very decorated living room and comfy feeling. Santa looking down at floor arranging shiny boxes, child hiding face in hands on stairs.

4I'm a kid Christmas morning standing at the top of the staircase catching Santa putting out presents. Santa doesn't know I'm there and I'm hiding. Very decorated living room and comfy feeling. Santa talking on phone or checking list, completely unaware of child silhouetted on top of stairs.

Their questionnaire

Useful to say what varies: ★★☆☆☆

Slider behaved as expected: ★★☆☆☆

Enjoyed the task: ★★★★★

Preferred: No preference

Uses image generators: A few times

Wanted to vary but could not: The tool did not seem to read and understand my edits when it was presented with them. I even tried varying the variance scale to see if that affected the outcome and for the most part did not.

Other: Good luck with your research.

Would do more: Yes

Participant 17 · Sep 25, 12:11

A cocker spaniel playing

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1

age, color, setting

3 words

new set · diversity 0.44

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A cocker spaniel playing, a tiny puppy cub, sunny park field, green grass background

2A cocker spaniel playing, an elderly silver-haired senior dog, cozy living room interior

3A cocker spaniel playing, a rare black and white coat, muddy swimming pool setting

4A cocker spaniel playing, a golden brown adult dog, snowy winter forest scene

Round 2

pose

1 word

edited the previous set · diversity 0.44

round 2 image 1round 2 image 2round 2 image 3round 2 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1change the pose to a playful tantrum with legs spread wide in the air

2change the pose to sitting upright on the carpet looking happy

3change the pose to lying down in the mud with paws splayed out

4change the pose to jumping through the air with tail wagging

Round 4

pose

1 word

edited the previous set · diversity 0.11

round 4 image 1round 4 image 2round 4 image 3round 4 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1change the pose to standing upright, lifting front paws high in the air

2change the pose to sitting calmly on the carpet with head tilted slightly upwards

3change the pose to stretching out horizontally, with all four paws extended

4change the pose to galloping or running with legs splayed out wide and mouth open

Round 6 Accepted

pose

1 word

edited the previous set · diversity 0.00

varied ★★★★★ matched ★★★★☆

“It varied the right thing but some of the dogs no longer looks like they're playing, like in my original prompt”

round 6 image 1round 6 image 2round 6 image 3round 6 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1change the puppy's pose from standing still to a dynamic run

2change the puppy's pose from standing still to a sit

3change the puppy's pose from standing still to a stand with paws off the floor

4change the puppy's pose from standing still to a lean-back against a fence

Participant 17 · Sep 25, 12:16

A girl in a Yukata at a firework festival

Prompt changed

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Participant 17 · Sep 25, 12:17

A woman (20s) in a Yukata at a firework festival

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis. The participant revised the prompt; it was: “A girl in a Yukata at a firework festival”.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1

yukata color and pattern

4 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.33

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1change the yukata to a bright red pattern with white cranes on it

2change the yukata to a pale green pattern with black bamboo stalks

3change the yukata to a vibrant pink pattern with gold geometric designs

4change the yukata to a deep indigo pattern with white cherry blossoms

Round 2 Accepted

framing (close up vs full body)

6 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.11

varied ★★★★★ matched ★★★★★

“They varied the right thing, but all the styles of Yukatas were only varied with colors but still very similar in style instead of some being more girly and cute and some being more simple and mature etc.”

round 2 image 1round 2 image 2round 2 image 3round 2 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1Switch to a close-up shot focusing only on the woman's face

2Change the framing to a full body shot

3Edit the framing to a medium shot with the woman from the waist up

4Adjust the framing to an over-the-shoulder shot

Their questionnaire

Useful to say what varies: ★★★★☆

Slider behaved as expected: ★★★☆☆

Enjoyed the task: ★★★★☆

Preferred: Edit these

Uses image generators: Monthly

Wanted to vary but could not: I wanted to have more variety in the axis i requested but when I slid the variety slider to be more varied, it seems like the tool also tended to vary things I didn't request, such as adding illustration style images when I didn't request any variety in the medium output. I also feel like the variety was on the extreme end. For example when requesting a variety in poses, I expected different varied but still natural poses, instead if I increased the slider, I tended to get very unnatural or physically impossible poses instead. The tool also ignored some of my prompt requests when I requested more variety. For example even when I specified that I wanted a black and white photo, if i slid the scale to more variety, it added color to the images etc. I felt like it was hard to get like a good amount of variety, while still only affecting the areas I wanted varied, and making sure my original prompt didn't change.

Would do more: Yes

Participant 18 · Sep 25, 12:54

A gardener is planning flowers

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Accepted

Flowers

1 word

edited the previous set · diversity 0.67

varied ★★★★★ matched ★★★★★

“They varies the flowers, but the gardener still stay as same.”

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A gardener is planning flowers, add a background with tall exotic orchids and purple lilies

2A gardener is planning flowers, change the flowers to bright red roses and yellow tulips

3A gardener is planning flowers, add white daisies and blue forget-me-nots in the pots

4(kept as it was)

Participant 18 · Sep 25, 12:59

A performance is taking place in the aquarium.

Prompt changed

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Participant 18 · Sep 25, 13:04

A animal performance is taking place in the aquarium.

Prompt changed

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis. The participant revised the prompt; it was: “A performance is taking place in the aquarium.”.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Participant 18 · Sep 25, 13:06

A do-

Prompt changed

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis. The participant revised the prompt; it was: “A animal performance is taking place in the aquarium.”.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Participant 18 · Sep 25, 13:07

The animal trainer is doing animal show.

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis. The participant revised the prompt; it was: “A do-”.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Accepted

The animal trainer is doing animal show.

7 words

new set · diversity 0.67

varied ★★★★★ matched ★★★★★

“They varied the right things, just some trainer are in wrong outfit.”

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1The animal trainer is doing animal show. A skilled female trainer in a red vest performs tricks with three vibrant parrots on a sunny stage.

2The animal trainer is doing animal show. An energetic male trainer in a blue suit juggles lions and tigers while a crowd cheers in a circus tent.

3The animal trainer is doing animal show. A diverse group of animal trainers performing with elephants, giraffes, and monkeys on a colorful outdoor stage at night.

4The animal trainer is doing animal show. A focused trainer in traditional ethnic clothing teaches seals to clap and dance under bright spotlights.

Participant 19 · Sep 25, 13:04

An idyllic setting of a family gathered around a barbecue and picnic table. The family is laughing, eating standard American cuisine, and generally enjoying each other's company.

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Accepted

I want families of different ethnicities and also I want the times of day to vary. For example, sunsets, midday, and golden hour images.

24 words

new set · diversity 0.89

varied ★★★★★ matched ★★★★★

“The variation in background settings (golden hour, sunset, etc.) is exactly how I envisioned.”

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1An idyllic setting of a family gathered around a barbecue and picnic table. The family is laughing, eating standard American cuisine, generally enjoying each other's company. A diverse multi-ethnic family: Black, Hispanic, and Asian parents with children, colorful clothes, vibrant garden background.

2An idyllic setting of a family gathered around a barbecue and picnic table. The family is laughing, eating standard American cuisine, and generally enjoying each other's company. A Caucasian family with blonde hair, blue eyes, dogs and cats nearby, bright midday sun, lush green park, clear blue sky.

3An idyllic setting of a family gathered around a barbecue and picnic table. The family is laughing, eating standard American cuisine, and generally enjoying each other's company. Sunset golden hour, warm orange sky, silhouettes of a multi-generational diverse family, burgers, hot dogs, smoke rising.

4An idyllic setting of a family gathered around a barbecue and picnic table. The family is laughing, eating standard American cuisine, and generally enjoying each other's company. Night time, moonlight, fairy lights, stars, diverse family eating pizza and fries, fireflies, cozy atmosphere.

Participant 20 · Sep 25, 13:04

A cozy rooftop cafe in a busy Indian city, with people enjoying coffee and snacks, realistic photography

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Accepted

time of day

3 words

new set · diversity 0.33

varied ★★★★★ matched ★★★★★

“The time of day changed clearly while the cafe setting stayed pretty consistent.”

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A cozy rooftop cafe in a busy Indian city, with people enjoying coffee and snacks, realistic photography, bright sunny midday

2A cozy rooftop cafe in a busy Indian city, with people enjoying coffee and snacks, realistic photography, golden hour sunset

3A cozy rooftop cafe in a busy Indian city, with people enjoying coffee and snacks, realistic photography, warm cozy night lights

4A cozy rooftop cafe in a busy Indian city, with people enjoying coffee and snacks, realistic photography, soft early morning sunrise

Participant 20 · Sep 25, 13:08

A modern Indian street food market at night, with colorful stalls, people eating snacks, realistic photography

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Accepted

weather conditions

2 words

new set · diversity 0.67

varied ★★★★★ matched ★★★★★

“The weather changes are very clear, while the night market setting stays consistent.”

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A modern Indian street food market at night, with colorful stalls, people eating snacks, realistic photography. Clear sunny night sky, bright stars visible, calm dry air, warm breeze.

2A modern Indian street food market at night, with colorful stalls, people eating snacks, realistic photography. Heavy rain falling, wet pavement reflections, people with umbrellas, rain-covered stalls.

3A modern Indian street food market at night, with colorful stalls, people eating snacks, realistic photography. Heavy fog rolling in, misty atmosphere, soft diffused lighting, mysterious mood.

4A modern Indian street food market at night, with colorful stalls, people eating snacks, realistic photography. Snow gently falling, winter blankets on shoulders, cold breath visible, festive lights.

Participant 19 · Sep 25, 13:09

I want two players from opposite teams locked in concentration during a sporting event. Their faces are wrought with concentration.

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Accepted

I want a more dynamic image of the sport or competition being played. Also, could the actual sport in question be varied, but distinguishable to what it actually is. For example, rugby, hockey, and American football players.

37 words

new set · diversity 1.00

varied ★★★★☆ matched ★★★★★

“While I appreciate the sporting discipline variation, I feel that the images are still quite static and not dynamic.”

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1I want two players from opposite teams locked in concentration during a sporting event. Their faces are wrought with concentration. Close-up shots of two intense athletes, one in red jersey, one in blue, staring deeply at each other, sweat, focus.

2I want two players from opposite teams locked in concentration during a sporting event. Their faces are wrought with concentration. Two hockey players, one in white gear, one in black, holding hockey sticks, ice rink background, pucks, crowds cheering.

3I want two players from opposite teams locked in concentration during a sporting event. Their faces are wrought with concentration. Two rugby players, muscular, wearing scrums and tough pads, pointing fingers, grass field, referees, spectators.

4I want two players from opposite teams locked in concentration during a sporting event. Their faces are wrought with concentration. Two American football players, helmets, pads, one in gold, one in silver, holding football, stadium lights, flags.

Participant 18 · Sep 25, 13:09

A server is serving food to the customer.

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Accepted

Food and server

3 words

new set · diversity 0.67

varied ★★★★★ matched ★★★★☆

“Two pictures kept the same server, but the rest varies the server and food as I requested.”

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A server is serving food to the customer. The server is an elegant woman in a white uniform, presenting a gourmet plated steak with vegetables on a fine dining table.

2A server is serving food to the customer. The server is a friendly man in a red apron, handing a plate of colorful sushi rolls and fresh salad to a smiling family.

3A server is serving food to the customer. The server holds a tray with hot pizza and burgers, while the customer enjoys an ice cream sundae and fruit dessert.

4A server is serving food to the customer. The server brings a basket of bread and a bowl of soup, while the customer eats a sandwich and drinks coffee at a cafe table.

Participant 20 · Sep 25, 13:12

A cozy independent bookstore with a small reading corner, warm lighting, bookshelves and a few visitors, realistic photography

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Accepted

interior design style

3 words

new set · diversity 0.56

varied ★★★★★ matched ★★★★☆

“The design styles are clearly different, though the futuristic one feels a bit less cozy than the others.”

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A cozy independent bookstore with a small reading corner, warm lighting, bookshelves and a few visitors, realistic photography, modern minimalist interior design, clean lines, white walls, geometric shelving.

2A cozy independent bookstore with a small reading corner, warm lighting, bookshelves and a few visitors, realistic photography, rustic farmhouse style, exposed beams, wooden floors, cozy textiles.

3A cozy independent bookstore with a small reading corner, warm lighting, bookshelves and a few visitors, realistic photography, Victorian eclectic interior, ornate moldings, vintage furniture, rich colors.

4A cozy independent bookstore with a small reading corner, warm lighting, bookshelves and a few visitors, realistic photography, sci-fi futuristic interior, neon accents, metallic shelves, high-tech atmosphere.

Participant 19 · Sep 25, 13:12

I want a scene of a father teaching his young son to fly a kite. The son has just managed to get the kite airborne and the father is helping his son ensure that it stays suspended.

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Accepted

I want father-son pairs of different ethnicities to capture a wide spectrum of father-son bonding over kite flying.

18 words

new set · diversity 0.78

varied ★★★★★ matched ★★★★★

“The AI agent following my directions to capture fathers and sons of many different ethnicities flying kites.”

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1I want a scene of a father teaching his young son to fly a kite. The son has just managed to get the kite airborne and the father is helping his son ensure that it stays suspended. A Caucasian father and son, both wearing casual spring clothes, smiling happily in a green park with colorful kites in the sky.

2I want a scene of a father teaching his young son to fly a kite. The son has just managed to get the kite airborne and the father is helping his son ensure that it stays suspended. An African American father and son, vibrant traditional clothing, joyful expressions, sunny roadside, large bright kite flying high, diverse background crowd watching.

3I want a scene of a father teaching his young son to fly a kite. The son has just managed to get the kite airborne and the father is helping his son ensure that it stays suspended. An East Asian father and son in matching blue kimonos, cherry blossom trees blooming, magical atmosphere, detailed faces, kite shaped like a dragon.

4I want a scene of a father teaching his young son to fly a kite. The son has just managed to get the kite airborne and the father is helping his son ensure that it stays suspended. A South Asian father and son, warm skin tones, colorful ethnic wear, lively village market background, birds flying, golden hour lighting, strong bond.

Participant 18 · Sep 25, 13:14

A customer is picking his car at the dealership store.

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Accepted

Customer, car type, car color

5 words

new set · diversity 0.67

varied ★★★★★ matched ★★★★☆

“They varied the right things just it does not really looks like customer in some pictures.”

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A customer is picking his car at the dealership store. A young woman in a bright dress standing next to a shiny black sports car.

2A customer is picking his car at the dealership store. An elderly man with a cane looking at a rugged red off-road SUV.

3A customer is picking his car at the dealership store. A diverse group of male customers selecting a sleek white electric sedan.

4A customer is picking his car at the dealership store. A happy man in a suit admiring a gold luxury convertible sports car.

Participant 20 · Sep 25, 13:15

A small mountain cabin beside a lake, surrounded by pine trees and mountains, realistic landscape photography

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Accepted

season

1 word

new set · diversity 0.89

varied ★★★★★ matched ★★★★★

“The four seasons are really clear, and the cabin and lake setting stays consistent.”

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A small mountain cabin beside a lake, surrounded by pine trees and mountains, realistic landscape photography. Winter season, heavy snow covering the cabin roof, frozen lake, snow-covered pine trees, icy mountains.

2A small mountain cabin beside a lake, surrounded by pine trees and mountains, realistic landscape photography. Vibrant spring scene, blooming wildflowers around cabin, lush green grass, melting ice on lake, blue sky.

3A small mountain cabin beside a lake, surrounded by pine trees and mountains, realistic landscape photography. Bright summer day, golden sunlight, lush green forest, people swimming in the calm blue lake.

4A small mountain cabin beside a lake, surrounded by pine trees and mountains, realistic landscape photography. Autumn season, colorful orange and red leaves, fallen leaves on ground, cabin with warm windows glowing.

Participant 19 · Sep 25, 13:17

I want a cat and dog baker pair creating delectable treats that they both can enjoy.

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Accepted

I want different dog and cat breeds represented in each of the four images. I also want further dynamism in the kitchen concerning the dog and cat. Perhaps they can be placing the treats in the oven, kneading dough, or similar.

41 words

new set · diversity 1.00

varied ★★★★☆ matched ★★★★★

“I like the variation in dog and cat breeds. However, I wish the images were less static and more dynamically oriented. In all four images, the pair is simply facing the camera with no large emphasis on action.”

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1I want a cat and dog baker pair creating delectable treats that they both can enjoy. A cute fluffy white Persian cat and a small golden retriever dog, both wearing chef hats and aprons, smiling while holding cookies.

2I want a cat and dog baker pair creating delectable treats that they both can enjoy. A energetic Siamese cat and a large German Shepherd dog, kneading dough together, flour everywhere, happy kitchen background.

3I want a cat and dog baker pair creating delectable treats that they both can enjoy. A black sleek Tiger cat and a colorfulbred Dalmatian dog, placing colorful cupcakes and cakes into a red oven, sparks of magic.

4I want a cat and dog baker pair creating delectable treats that they both can enjoy. An orange tabby cat and a French Bulldog, serving ice cream and pastries to each other, forks in mouths, joyful kitchen party.

Participant 18 · Sep 25, 13:17

A family is going out for picnic.

Stopped before choosing an axis

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Participant 20 · Sep 25, 13:17

A charming neighborhood bakery on a quiet street, with fresh pastries in the window, a few customers outside, realistic photography

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Accepted

bakery architecture style

3 words

new set · diversity 0.56

varied ★★★★★ matched ★★★★☆

“The architecture styles are clearly different, although the first one feels a bit more like a cottage than a neighborhood bakery.”

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A charming neighborhood bakery on a quiet street, with fresh pastries in the window, a few customers outside, realistic photography, rustic cottage style architecture, stone walls, thatched roof.

2A charming neighborhood bakery on a quiet street, with fresh pastries in the window, a few customers outside, realistic photography, modern minimalist architecture, clean white lines, large glass facade.

3A charming neighborhood bakery on a quiet street, with fresh pastries in the window, a few customers outside, realistic photography, Victorian brick architecture, ornate windows, cozy lamp posts.

4A charming neighborhood bakery on a quiet street, with fresh pastries in the window, a few customers outside, realistic photography, Mediterranean style architecture, terracotta tiles, colorful stucco walls.

Their questionnaire

study_round: 0

Useful to say what varies: ★★★★★

Slider behaved as expected: ★★★★★

Enjoyed the task: ★★★★★

Preferred: Both, for different things

Uses image generators: Weekly or more

Wanted to vary but could not: I wanted to vary the people and their activities while keeping the same setting.

Would do more: Yes

Participant 18 · Sep 25, 13:19

A family is eating at the restaurant.

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Accepted

Different food, different ethnicity

4 words

new set · diversity 0.67

varied ★★★★★ matched ★★★★★

“The variety the correct thing.”

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A family is eating at the restaurant. They are Asian parents with a daughter, enjoying traditional dumplings and sushi on wooden tables.

2A family is eating at the restaurant. A Caucasian father, mother, and two kids share a large pizza, pasta, and colorful salads in a cozy dining room.

3A family is eating at the restaurant. Black parents and their two children enjoy spicy Curri rice, chicken tikka, and mango lassi in a warm decor.

4A family is eating at the restaurant. Hispanic family of four eats tacos, burritos, guacamole, and fresh fruit juices in a lively Mexican-style eatery.

Their questionnaire

study_round: 0

Useful to say what varies: ★★★☆☆

Slider behaved as expected: ★★★★☆

Enjoyed the task: ★★★★★

Preferred: Edit these

Uses image generators: Weekly or more

Wanted to vary but could not: The tool vary the people but they kinda share similar looking face. Also when I describe something more vague, it cannot understand it and give me the wrong image.

Would do more: Yes

Participant 19 · Sep 25, 13:21

I want representatives of different religions meditating together in a picturesque zen garden. They are united as one in their mediation.

Prompt changed

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Participant 19 · Sep 25, 13:23

I want representatives of different religions meditating together in a picturesque zen garden. They are united as one in their mediation, visible members of different religions meditating together

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis. The participant revised the prompt; it was: “I want representatives of different religions meditating together in a picturesque zen garden. They are united as one in their mediation.”.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Accepted

I really want an emphasis on different and visible members of different religions meditating together. To show this emphasis, we could also incorporate a visible variation in ethnicity. Nevertheless. they are united together.

33 words

new set · diversity 1.00

varied ★★★★★ matched ★★★★★

“The AI images really highlighted the spectrum of religions that I wanted to demonstrate meditating together.”

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1I want representatives of different religions meditating together in a picturesque zen garden. They are united as one in their mediation, visible members of different religions meditating together. Peaceful zen garden, koi pond, cherry blossoms, incense.

2I want representatives of different religions meditating together in a picturesque zen garden. They are united as one in their mediation, visible members of different religions meditating together. A diverse group: Asian Buddhist monk, Hindu priest with turban, Muslim woman in hijab, Christian nun, Jewish man with kippah, all meditating.

3I want representatives of different religions meditating together in a picturesque zen garden. They are united as one in their mediation, visible members of different religions meditating together. Strong focus on ethnicity: Black man, Latina woman, Middle Eastern man, South Asian woman, Caucasian elder, African American priest, colorful robes.

4I want representatives of different religions meditating together in a picturesque zen garden. They are united as one in their mediation, visible members of different religions meditating together. Close-up faces showing devout expressions, symbols of religions (cross, star of david, crescent, om) on cloths, holding hands in unity.

Their questionnaire

study_round: 0

Useful to say what varies: ★★★★★

Slider behaved as expected: ★★★★★

Enjoyed the task: ★★★★★

Preferred: Generate new

Uses image generators: Weekly or more

Wanted to vary but could not: While the tool was great at incorporating the visual variation of the components that I wanted, I wish it could better create the visual differences in actions that I desired. I felt images were a bit too static when I wanted dynamism.

Would do more: Yes

Participant 21 · Sep 25, 13:36

A forest during dawn with cedar trees, oak trees, a light fog and a caribou with a large rack.

Stopped before choosing an axis

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Participant 21 · Sep 25, 13:38

A misty forest with oak and cedar and a male caribou.

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Accepted

No caribou, elk instead. Large male elk. More underbrush in forest. A few mushrooms.

14 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.44

varied ★★★★☆ matched ★★★★☆

“The elk looks a little weird, but overall the images are very good. A few more leaves from an oak would have completed these.”

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1Replace the caribou with a large male elk with impressive antlers.

2Remove the caribou and replace it with a large male elk.

3Add a large male elk instead of the caribou, keeping the same pose.

4Replace the caribou with a huge, majestic male elk.

Participant 21 · Sep 25, 13:46

A Robin pulling a worm from the ground on a rainy morning.

Not what they wanted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1

A red Robin, one from north America. Pulling the worm up as it flies away

15 words

new set · diversity 0.33

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A red Robin from North America pulling a worm from the ground on a rainy morning.

2A red Robin from North America pulling a worm up as it flies away on a rainy morning.

3A vivid red Robin from North America pulling a wriggling worm from the wet ground.

4A classic North American red Robin pulling a worm upward as the creature flies.

Round 2 Rejected

A red Robin, one from north America. Pulling the worm up as it flies away

15 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.33

varied ★★★☆☆ matched ★★★☆☆

“First, they dont look like north American red robins. Similar but not quite. Not able to get the worm mid flight for some reason.”

round 2 image 1round 2 image 2round 2 image 3round 2 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1Apply vibrant red coloring to the bird's feathers, emphasizing its Northern American Robin features. Keep the other elements as they are.

2Add motion blur and dynamic wings to the bird as it flies upwards, with the worm flailing in mid-air. Keep the rest of the image the same.

3Pose the bird facing right, with the worm and its body curling dramatically as it is pulled out to the right side of the frame. Keep the rest of the image the same.

4Modify the worm so it appears to be taking flight while attached to the bird's beak. Change the background to include a mossy log base instead of mud. Keep the rest of the image the same.

Participant 21 · Sep 25, 13:55

A fruit salad made from Asian fruits like lychee, starfruit and dragonflies. On a rice cake.

Prompt changed

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1

A prepared fruit salad. On a soft rice cake.

9 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.67

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1Add a spoon and a small glass of juice beside the fruit salad on the rice cake.

2Add a decorative garnish of mint leaves and a cherry on top of the fruit salad.

3Transform the fruit salad into a platter with several different fruits arranged artistically on the rice cake.

4Make the fruit salad look freshly diced and mixed with a light syrup glaze on the rice cake.

Round 2

A prepared fruit salad. On a soft rice cake.

9 words

new set · diversity 0.67

round 2 image 1round 2 image 2round 2 image 3round 2 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A fruit salad made from Asian fruits like lychee, starfruit and dragonflies. On a rice cake. Fresh, vibrant colors, detailed textures, close-up shot, delicious looking.

2A fruit salad made from Asian fruits like lychee, starfruit and dragonflies. On a soft rice cake. Bowl filled with creamy yogurt sauce, mint leaves, berries, and scale.

3A fruit salad made from Asian fruits like lychee, starfruit and dragonflies. On a rice cake. Elegant gold plate, white napkin, candlelight, romantic dinner setting, night background.

4A fruit salad made from Asian fruits like lychee, starfruit and dragonflies. On a rice cake. Traditional wooden serving board, hands holding chopsticks, festive Asian market backdrop, bright daylight.

Round 3

A prepared fruit salad. On a soft rice cake. Not in a bowl, more cake like and prepared

18 words

new set · diversity 0.67

round 3 image 1round 3 image 2round 3 image 3round 3 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A fruit salad made from Asian fruits like lychee, starfruit and dragonflies. On a rice cake. Vibrant colors, fresh ingredients, detailed texture, close up food photography.

2A fruit salad made from Asian fruits like lychee, starfruit and dragonflies. On a soft rice cake. Not in a bowl. Gallant arrangement, artfully spread pile of fruit directly on cake surface.

3A fruit salad made from Asian fruits like lychee, starfruit and dragonflies. On a soft rice cake. More cake-like and prepared. Slice of fluffy white sponge cake topped with the exotic fruit mix.

4A fruit salad made from Asian fruits like lychee, starfruit and dragonflies. On a soft rice cake. Highly prepared dessert plating. Chopped fruits melted into a creamy rice cake base, garnished with mint.

Participant 21 · Sep 25, 14:03

A fruit salad made from Asian fruits like lychee, starfruit and dragonfruit. On a rice cake.

Not what they wanted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis. The participant revised the prompt; it was: “A fruit salad made from Asian fruits like lychee, starfruit and dragonflies. On a rice cake.”.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Rejected

A prepared fruit salad with dragonfruit. On a soft rice cake.

11 words

new set · diversity 0.67

varied ★★☆☆☆ matched ★★☆☆☆

“Not showing a prepared fruit salad. No dragon fruit. Rice cake looks more like a dry rice cake than an actual cake”

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A fruit salad made from Asian fruits like lychee, starfruit and dragonfruit. On a rice cake. Fresh, vibrant colors, top-down view, ceramic plate, bright kitchen lighting.

2A fruit salad made from Asian fruits like lychee, starfruit and dragonfruit. On a soft rice cake. Elegant silver platter, garnished with mint leaves, fancy gold cutlery, banquet setting.

3A fruit salad made from Asian fruits like lychee, starfruit and dragonfruit. On a soft rice cake. Nighttime picnic setting, fireflies, moonlight, soft focus, purple and pink ambient lighting.

4A fruit salad made from Asian fruits like lychee, starfruit and dragonfruit. On a soft rice cake. Close-up macro shot, water droplets on fruit skin, colorful wooden serving board, artisanal style.

Participant 21 · Sep 25, 14:06

A daytime, sunny image of a lake with a pink rowing boat, oars out, sitting perfectly still. No people anywhere in the image. A ripple in the water eminating from a single water drop from an oar.

Left after 1 round

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1

Less realistic amd more like a detailed sketched image

9 words

new set · diversity 1.00

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A daytime, sunny image of a lake with a pink rowing boat, oars out, sitting perfectly still. No people anywhere in the image. A ripple in the water eminating from a single water drop from an oar. Bright vibrant colors, lush green trees, fluffy colorful clouds, happy sun, cheerful atmosphere, picturesque scenic lake.

2A daytime, sunny image of a lake with a pink rowing boat, oars out, sitting perfectly still. No people anywhere in the image. A ripple in the water eminating from a single water drop from an oar. Detailed black and white sketch style, intricate lines, cross-hatching, artistic drawing, focus on boat details and water texture.

3A daytime, sunny image of a lake with a pink rowing boat, oars out, sitting perfectly still. No people anywhere in the image. A ripple in the water eminating from a single water drop from an oar. Cartoon style, cute and playful, pastel colors, big smiling sun, funny clouds, magical fairies around the lake, vibrant flowers.

4A daytime, sunny image of a lake with a pink rowing boat, oars out, sitting perfectly still. No people anywhere in the image. A ripple in the water eminating from a single water drop from an oar. Watercolor painting style, soft edges, dreamy atmosphere, artistic brushstrokes, colorful background, birds flying, distant mountains.

Participant 21 · Sep 25, 14:12

A sketched image of a pink rowing boat, oars mostly pulled in, sitting still in the middle of a lake. Perfectly still water except for a single ripple coming from a dripping oar.

Prompt changed

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1

Much less realistic

3 words

new set · diversity 0.11

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A sketched image of a pink rowing boat, oars mostly pulled in, sitting still in the middle of a lake. The water is flat and glassy, rendered in a childish crayon doodle style with messy, emerging lines and bold outlines instead of realistic reflections.

2A sketched image of a pink rowing boat, oars mostly pulled in, sitting still in the middle of a lake. Perfectly still water except for a single ripple coming from a dripping oar. The sketch is an energetic, cartoonish black marker drawing with wobbly, exaggerated shapes and high contrast.

3A sketched image of a pink rowing boat, oars mostly pulled in, sitting still in the middle of a lake. Perfectly still water except for a single ripple coming from a dripping oar. The image is a soft, dreamy pastel watercolor sketch with bleeding colors and loose, abstract textures.

4A sketched image of a pink rowing boat, oars mostly pulled in, sitting still in the middle of a lake. Perfectly still water except for a single ripple coming from a dripping oar. Rendered as a childish, chaotic pencil scribble with jagged lines, uneven shading, and a crude, non-representational look.

Participant 21 · Sep 25, 14:18

A sketched image of a pink rowing boat, oars mostly pulled in, sitting still in the middle of a lake. Perfectly still water except for a single ripple coming from a dripping oar, pastel style

Not what they wanted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis. The participant revised the prompt; it was: “A sketched image of a pink rowing boat, oars mostly pulled in, sitting still in the middle of a lake. Perfectly still water except for a single ripple coming from a dripping oar.”.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Rejected

Much less realistic

3 words

new set · diversity 1.00

varied ★★☆☆☆ matched ★★☆☆☆

“Not able to change from a realistic image to a pastel image.”

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A sketched image of a pink rowing boat, oars mostly pulled in, sitting still in the middle of a lake. Perfectly still water except for a single ripple coming from a dripping oar, pastel style. Detailed linework, clean sketch, precise geometry, calm lake background, sworn detail engineering view.

2A sketched image of a pink rowing boat, oars mostly pulled in, sitting still in the middle of a lake. Pastel style, whimsical cartoon version, cute pink boat with smiling face, colorful flowers, fluffy clouds, happy birds, magic sparkles, playful kids watching from shore.

3A sketched image of a pink rowing boat, oars mostly pulled in, sitting still in the middle of a lake. Loose abstract splatter art, vibrant chaotic pastel colors, swirlingshapes, dreamy faces in sky, fuzzy lakes, mountains, spies, asteroids, aliens watching.

4A sketched image of a pink rowing boat, oars mostly pulled in, sitting still in the middle of a lake. Dark gothic sketch style, goth lady sitting in boat night time, moonlight, bats, stars, spooky trees, mysterious fog, detailed вакансииemdalls and ribbons on boat.

Participant 22 · Sep 25, 14:13

a middle-aged woman with greying hair playing a MMORPG on a computer.

Not what they wanted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Rejected

It should look like a different woman in every picture. There also should be more color variety in her clothing, and her expression should differ.

25 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.44

varied ★★★★☆ matched ★★★☆☆

“It changed woman, expressions and colors of the clothing, but it also changed hair color which I didn't ask and was a crucial part of the prompt.”

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1change the woman's hair color to bright red and her clothing to a vibrant floral dress. Give her a joyful, laughing expression.

2change the woman's hair color to short platinum blonde and her clothing to a bright yellow jacket. Give her a surprised, wide-eyed expression.

3change the woman's hair color to dyed brown with blonde streaks and her clothing to a purple sweater. Give her a focused, intense expression.

4change the woman's hair color to natural dark auburn and her clothing to a white blouse. Give her a bored, slightly annoyed expression.

Participant 22 · Sep 25, 14:20

A calico cat with a sophisticated expression is sitting at a table in a restaurant. A human is humbly and almost fearfully showing her the best cat food can they have at the place.

Not what they wanted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Rejected

The human should be showing a food can to the cat, almost as if presenting it to her. The image should have a wider focus, not so close-up. Show more of the restaurant. The human is a waiter/waitress!

38 words

new set · diversity 0.67

varied ★★★★☆ matched ★★★★☆

“Image 2 and 3 are the closest to what I asked and wanted, also in terms of the human's expression that is both humble and fearful. Image number 1 didn't widen the focus on the image, and the human in image 4 is showing not one can, but three on a plate.”

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A calico cat with a sophisticated expression is sitting at a table in a restaurant. A human is humbly and almost fearfully showing her the best cat food can they have at the place. The human is a nervous waiter holding a small cat food can, presenting it politely to the cat. Close-up on faces.

2A calico cat with a sophisticated expression is sitting at a table in a restaurant. A human is humbly and almost fearfully showing her the best cat food can they have at the place. The human is a elegant waitress presenting a fancy gold can. Wide shot showing busy restaurant, other diners, chandeliers, and decor.

3A calico cat with a sophisticated expression is sitting at a table in a restaurant. A human is humbly and almost fearfully showing her the best cat food can they have at the place. The human is a timid young waiter offering a nutrient-rich can. Wide angle view of the luxurious dining hall with booths and windows.

4A calico cat with a sophisticated expression is sitting at a table in a restaurant. A human is humbly and almost fearfully showing her the best cat food can they have at the place. The human is a professional chef/waitress presenting a variety of gourmet cans. Sunset lighting, wide restaurant interior with staff and patrons.

Participant 21 · Sep 25, 14:24

A 2 lane highway, with a 90 degree lazy turn, trees coming within 2 ft of tbd road.

Stopped before choosing an axis

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Participant 22 · Sep 25, 14:26

A popular Japanese idol is taking a picture with a fan. She has twintails, blonde hair, natural make up and a colorful outfit. She's trying her best to conceal how uneasy and disgusted she feels interacting with that particular fan.

Prompt changed

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Participant 22 · Sep 25, 14:29

A popular Japanese idol is taking a picture with a fan. She has twintails, blonde hair, natural make up and a colorful outfit. She's trying her best to conceal how uneasy and disgusted she feels interacting with that particular fan, the fan is an otaku, and both the idol and the fan are shown in full body

Not what they wanted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis. The participant revised the prompt; it was: “A popular Japanese idol is taking a picture with a fan. She has twintails, blonde hair, natural make up and a colorful outfit. She's trying her best to conceal how uneasy and disgusted she feels interacting with that particular fan.”.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1

The fan should be a fan of the idol, a human, a "otaku"! The images should show the full body of both the idol and the fan. Also, make the idol's hair color different in each picture.

37 words

new set · diversity 1.00

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A popular Japanese idol is taking a picture with a fan. She has twintails, blonde hair, natural make up and a colorful outfit. She looks uneasy and disgusted, trying to hide it. The fan is an otaku boy, holding a poster of the idol, wearing glasses and hoodie, holding a camera. Both full body, smiling勉强ly, backstage setting.

2A popular Japanese idol is taking a picture with a fan. She has twintails, blonde hair, natural make up and a colorful outfit. She seems uncomfortable. The fan is an enthusiastic otaku girl, long pink hair, colorful cosplay, holding lightsabers and merch, cheering. Both full body, idol looking away.

3A popular Japanese idol is taking a picture with a fan. She has twintails, RED hair, natural make up and a colorful outfit. She looks forced and uneasy. The fan is a handsome otaku man, black hair, anime style clothes, holding a big microphone and fan cards, both full body shot.

4A popular Japanese idol is taking a picture with a fan. She has twintails, BROWN hair, natural make up and a colorful outfit. Disguised emotion of disgust. The fan is a young otaku girl, curly blonde hair, skirt, holding a tablet showing idol photos, holding gifts. Both full body, photographers around.

Round 2 Rejected

The otaku and the idol should be shown in full body. The idol's hair color is different in each picture. The okatu is a male.

25 words

edited the previous set · diversity 1.00

varied ★★★☆☆ matched ★★☆☆☆

“Somehow, the girl keeps holding a cooling fan. The first picture doesn't even have an actual fan (otaku). Only one image shows a different hair color. Only two pictures show the full body of the idol and her otaku. It doesn't look like the idol is doing anything to conceal her feelings. The disgust is at full display.”

round 2 image 1round 2 image 2round 2 image 3round 2 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A popular Japanese idol is taking a picture with a fan. She has green hair, twintails, natural make up and a colorful outfit. She's trying her best to conceal how uneasy and disgusted she feels interacting with that particular fan, the fan is an otaku, and both the idol and the fan are shown in full body. Add a city background with some buildings.

2A popular Japanese idol is taking a picture with a fan. She has red hair, twin braids, natural make up and a colorful outfit. She's trying her best to conceal how uneasy and disgusted she feels interacting with that particular fan, the fan is an otaku, and both the idol and the fan are shown in full body. Add some props like a microphone and stage lights in the background.

3A popular Japanese idol is taking a picture with a fan. She has black hair with pink highlights in buns, natural make up and a colorful outfit. She's trying her best to conceal how uneasy and disgusted she feels interacting with that particular fan, the fan is an otaku, and both the idol and the fan are shown in full body. Add a park or garden background with some trees and flowers.

4A popular Japanese idol is taking a picture with a fan. She has silver hair in a long ponytail, natural make up and a colorful outfit. She's trying her best to conceal how uneasy and disgusted she feels interacting with that particular fan, the fan is an otaku, and both the idol and the fan are shown in full body. Add a crowd of people and some event banners in the background.

Participant 22 · Sep 25, 14:35

A sweating, cute humanized rabbit, wanting to show off, tries lifting a heavy kettlebell. It fails. Animals around it laugh.

Not what they wanted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1

The rabbit and other animals should be humanized, anthropomorphized. The angle should be wider, showing a much bigger picture. The rabbit should be shown in the act of trying to lift. More dynamism!

33 words

new set · diversity 0.67

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A sweating, cute humanized rabbit wanting to show off tries lifting a heavy kettlebell. It fails. Animals around it laugh. Close-up action shot, rabbit straining muscles, kettlebell lifting mid-air, dynamic pose, sweat flying.

2A sweating, cute humanized rabbit wanting to show off tries lifting a heavy kettlebell. It fails. Animals around it laugh. Wide angle, huge stadium crowd of diverse humanized animals watching, rabbit center stage struggling, epic scale.

3A sweating, cute humanized rabbit wanting to show off tries lifting a heavy kettlebell. It fails. Animals around it laugh. Low dramatic angle looking up at rabbit, heavy kettlebell bending slightly, muscles rippling, intense effort expression.

4A sweating, cute humanized rabbit wanting to show off tries lifting a heavy kettlebell. It fails. Animals around it laugh. Panoramic wide shot, athletic arena, rabbit falling back comically, shocked humanized animal friends, bright lights, spectators everywhere.

Round 2

The rabbit and other animals should be anthropomorphized. The angle should be wider, showing a much bigger picture. The rabbit should be shown in the act of trying to lift, and it fails

33 words

new set · diversity 0.56

round 2 image 1round 2 image 2round 2 image 3round 2 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A sweating, cute humanized rabbit, wanting to show off, tries lifting a heavy kettlebell. It fails. Animals around it laugh. Anthropomorphized rabbit and animals with clothes and speech bubbles, funny expressions.

2A sweating, cute humanized rabbit, wanting to show off, tries lifting a heavy kettlebell. It fails. Animals around it laugh. Antomorphomorphized wide anime angle shot showing a village square, many laughing animals watching from balconies, huge crowd.

3A sweating, cute humanized rabbit, wanting to show off, tries lifting a heavy kettlebell. It fails. Animals around it laugh. Full anthropomorphized style. Wide angle shot capturing the rabbit's struggle face and the surrounding animals' mockery from all directions.

4A sweating, cute humanized rabbit, wanting to show off, tries lifting a heavy kettlebell. It fails. Animals around it laugh. Deeply anthropomorphized characters with distinct human outfits. Ultra-wide aerial view showing landscape, trees, and many diverse animal friends laughing below.

Round 3

Show a bigger picture. We look at the rabbit from a bigger distance. The rabbit should be anthropomorphized.

18 words

new set · diversity 0.56

round 3 image 1round 3 image 2round 3 image 3round 3 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A sweating, cute humanized rabbit, wanting to show off, tries lifting a heavy kettlebell. It fails. Animals around it laugh. Wide shot: rabbit is small in a large bustling town square, showing scale.

2A sweating, cute humanized rabbit, wanting to show off, tries lifting a heavy kettlebell. It fails. Animals around it laugh. Aerial view: rabbit in a meadow, tiny compared to giant trees and a distant village horizon.

3A sweating, cute humanized rabbit, wanting to show off, tries lifting a heavy kettlebell. It fails. Animals around it laugh. Isolated landscape: rabbit on a high hill, vast empty sky and mountains in background.

4A sweating, cute humanized rabbit, wanting to show off, tries lifting a heavy kettlebell. It fails. Animals around it laugh. Nighttime cityscape: rabbit on a rooftop, neon lights, huge city skyline visible in distance.

Round 5 Rejected

Take the first generated picture, make the rabbit more anthromorphized, add more distance to the view, widening the picture.

19 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.44

varied ★☆☆☆☆ matched ★☆☆☆☆

“I don't know what went wrong but it's a complete failure. Only two of the rabbits are anthromorphized, only two are dealing with a kettlebell (and not shown dynamically as they try to lift it), only two have animals laughing at the rabbit. I tried with editing, but it didn't work.”

round 5 image 1round 5 image 2round 5 image 3round 5 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1Add trees and sky background, move the rabbit to the center, add legs.

2Transform the rabbit into an anthropomorphic character with clothes, body shape, and human-like features.

3Add a gym background and weights, increase the size of the rabbit.

4Add a scenic countryside background, add arms and legs to the rabbit, move it to the center.

Their questionnaire

study_round: 0

Slider behaved as expected: ★★☆☆☆

Useful to say what varies: ★★★★☆

Enjoyed the task: ★★★★★

Preferred: Both, for different things

Uses image generators: A few times

Wanted to vary but could not: It seemed to have an issue to move from close-ups to full-body, wider views. It had a hard time following instructions about anthromorphization of animals, it couldn't understand context (if I write about an idol and her fan, it should be obvious that I'm not talking about a cooling fan), it didn't always make changes that I specifically asked (hair color, for example) and it appeared to have difficulty showing dynamic movement in action.

Other: I just want to wish the very best to every single person involved with this research!

Would do more: Yes

Participant 23 · Sep 25, 14:38

fishes swimming in the sky over an alpine village

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1

type of fish

3 words

edited the previous set · diversity 1.00

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1fishes swimming in the sky over an alpine village add some colorful tropical fish and a coral reef in the foreground

2fishes swimming in the sky over an alpine village add a large detailed shark next to the smaller fish

3fishes swimming in the sky over an alpine village add a school of golden carp with ornate fins

4fishes swimming in the sky over an alpine village add a small pufferfish and a seahorse near the village

Round 2 Accepted

type of fish

3 words

new set · diversity 0.78

varied ★★★★★ matched ★★★★★

round 2 image 1round 2 image 2round 2 image 3round 2 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1fishes swimming in the sky over an alpine village. Small colorful tropical fish like angelfish and goldfish, clouds, mountains, quaint houses, magical atmosphere, sunset.

2fishes swimming in the sky over an alpine village. Large majestic sharks and whales flying through clouds, snow-capped peaks, cozy village below, starry night sky.

3fishes swimming in the sky over an alpine village. School of elegant fancy koi fish with long flowing tails, bright colors, alpine chalets, pine trees, moonlight.

4fishes swimming in the sky over an alpine village. Underwater creatures like seahorses and clownfish in the sky, blue sky, fluffy clouds, snowy mountains, happy villagers watching.

Participant 23 · Sep 25, 14:41

a girl in traditional oktoberfest attire is walking among the tables of a busy roadside stall in vietnam

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1

ethnicity of the girl

4 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.78

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1a girl with East Asian features in traditional oktoberfest attire is walking among the tables of a busy roadside stall in vietnam

2a girl with dark skin and African features in traditional oktoberfest attire is walking among the tables of a busy roadside stall in vietnam

3a girl with European features and blonde hair in traditional oktoberfest attire is walking among the tables of a busy roadside stall in vietnam

4a girl with South Asian features in traditional oktoberfest attire is walking among the tables of a busy roadside stall in vietnam

Round 2 Accepted

setting of the roadside stall

5 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.78

varied ★★★★★ matched ★★★★★

round 2 image 1round 2 image 2round 2 image 3round 2 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1a girl in traditional oktoberfest attire is walking among the tables of a busy roadside stall in vietnam with a vibrant night market background illuminated by neon lights and string lights, with vendors selling beer and grilled meats.

2a girl in traditional oktoberfest attire is walking among the tables of a busy roadside stall in vietnam near a coastal area, with the ocean and a sunset visible in the background.

3a girl in traditional oktoberfest attire is walking among the tables of a busy roadside stall in vietnam in a lush green rural setting with paddy fields and traditional thatched-roof houses in the distance.

4a girl in traditional oktoberfest attire is walking among the tables of a busy roadside stall in vietnam in an urban city center with modern skyscrapers and busy traffic visible in the background.

Participant 21 · Sep 25, 14:41

A colour swatch of chalk paints against a dark cherry wood table

Not what they wanted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Rejected

Colour swatches, not pots

4 words

new set · diversity 1.00

varied ★★★★☆ matched ★★★☆☆

“A colour swatch is like a bunch of white paper with a sample of each colour on each page.fanned out. No pots of paint, no hands.”

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A colour swatch of chalk paints against a dark cherry wood table. Close-up of paint pots, tin containers with colorful lids, wood grain texture, dust, chalk labels, shows branding, tools.

2A colour swatch of chalk paints against a dark cherry wood table. Multiple flat rectangular color swatches in pastels, bold hues, oranges, blues, greens, reds, yellows, neatly arranged on the table.

3A colour swatch of chalk paints against a dark cherry wood table. الفنية�� swatches being painted on the table surface by hands, brushes, pastel mixed colors,畫布質感,dark wood background.

4A colour swatch of chalk paints against a dark cherry wood table. Bustling workshop vibe, shelves full of chalk paint tins, artists holding swatch books/pages showing diverse colors,银行存款 notes compare.

Their questionnaire

study_round: 0

Useful to say what varies: ★★★★☆

Slider behaved as expected: ★☆☆☆☆

Enjoyed the task: ★★★★★

Preferred: Generate new

Uses image generators: A few times

Wanted to vary but could not: It didnt vary enough. It barely changes the images at all . But I suppose that's what generate new is for.

Would do more: Yes

Participant 23 · Sep 25, 14:45

a labradoodle is drinking alchool in the morning in his own house

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1

type of alchoolic beverage

4 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.78

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1a labradoodle is drinking vodka tonic in the morning in his own house

2a labradoodle is drinking a beer in the morning in his own house

3a labradoodle is drinking a red wine glass in the morning in his own house

4a labradoodle is drinking a bowl of punch in the morning in his own house

Round 2 Accepted

style of forniture in the room

6 words

new set · diversity 0.78

varied ★★★★☆ matched ★★★★☆

round 2 image 1round 2 image 2round 2 image 3round 2 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1a labradoodle is drinking alcohol in the morning in his own house. Minimalist white furniture, clean lines, beige sofas, simple wooden tables, morning sunlight, serious expression.

2a labradoodle is drinking alcohol in the morning in his own house. Luxurious Victorian furniture, heavy velvet armchairs, ornate gold framed mirrors, dark wood cabinets, cozy atmosphere.

3a labradoodle is drinking alcohol in the morning in his own house. Modern colorful furniture, bright neon chairs, futuristic glass tables, bold patterns, vibrant living room, dog looking drunk.

4a labradoodle is drinking alcohol in the morning in his own house. Rustic farmhouse furniture, distressed wood tables, cozy Knitted cushions, Фарнсворс style lamps, warm candlelight, morning vibe.

Participant 23 · Sep 25, 14:47

a parying mantis is holding wild flowers picked in a field

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1

type of wild flowers

4 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.78

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1a praying mantis is holding wild flowers picked in a field with large red poppies and blue cornflowers

2a praying mantis is holding wild flowers picked in a field with small yellow daisies and white Queen Anne's Lace

3a praying mantis is holding wild flowers picked in a field with colorful exotic orchids and birds of paradise

4a praying mantis is holding wild flowers picked in a field with purple lavender and green foliage

Round 2 Accepted

camera angles (from above, macro etc.)

6 words

new set · diversity 0.78

varied ★★★★★ matched ★★★★★

round 2 image 1round 2 image 2round 2 image 3round 2 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A praying mantis is holding wild flowers picked in a field. Top-down bird's eye view, looking straight down at the mantis and colorful flowers on green grass, overhead angle.

2A praying mantis is holding wild flowers picked in a field. Extreme close-up macro shot, detailed insect eyes and antennae, texture of flowers, shallow depth of field, nature background.

3A praying mantis is holding wild flowers picked in a field. Side profile view, butterfly camera angle, mantis standing tall in wildflowers, soft sunlight, scenic meadow background, artistic lighting.

4A praying mantis is holding wild flowers picked in a field. Low angle worm's eye view, looking up at the giant mantis holding flowers, dramatic sky, towering grass, adventurous perspective.

Participant 24 · Sep 25, 14:49

Electronic shaver sold at a store

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1

Types of electronic shaver, store interior design

7 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.78

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1In the background, add a luxurious high-end cosmetics store interior with marble shelves and warm lighting.

2In the background, change the setting to a large retail electronics department store with bright fluorescent lighting and busy shoppers.

3In the background, add a minimalist modern boutique interior with wooden shelves and soft ambient lighting.

4Change the shaver to a foil shaver with a white and silver body, and add a coupon in the background.

Round 2

Types of electronic shaver, store interior design

7 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.22

round 2 image 1round 2 image 2round 2 image 3round 2 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1replace the store background with a high-end boutique featuring marble floors and gold-trimmed shelves

2change the store background to a crowded electronics retail environment with bright overhead lighting

3replace the store background with a minimalist showroom with simple wooden shelves and track lighting

4change the product from a rotary electric shaver to a foil electric shaver while keeping the store as a generic aisle

Round 3

camera angle, viewpoint

3 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.44

round 3 image 1round 3 image 2round 3 image 3round 3 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1View from a first-person perspective looking down at the package being held by a hand.

2Change the camera angle to a low,worm's-eye view looking up at the box on a counter.

3Change the viewpoint to a high-angle shot looking down at the box placed on a glass table.

4View from a direct eye-level side profile of the box on a display counter.

Round 4

Where the product is placed

5 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.67

round 4 image 1round 4 image 2round 4 image 3round 4 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1Add a hand holding the electronic shaver box in the center of the store.

2Place the electronic shaver box on a display table in a busy electronics store with people shopping in the background.

3Position the electronic shaver box on a minimalist glass shelf in a high-end retail boutique.

4Put the electronic shaver box on a countertop next to other grooming products in a drugstore.

Round 5 Accepted

number of products around

4 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.67

varied ★★★★☆ matched ★★★★★

“All the pictures are unnatural in that it's too focused on the subject and it does not blend in with surrounding environment”

round 5 image 1round 5 image 2round 5 image 3round 5 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1Add a few other electronic shavers and grooming products on the shelves in the background.

2Add a crowd of shoppers browsing electronics in the background behind the display.

3Place a few related grooming accessories on the table next to the shaver box.

4Add a row of many different models of electric shavers on the counter next to the main product.

Participant 23 · Sep 25, 14:50

a group of friends around a table chatting and laughing

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Accepted

setting (bar, house etc)

4 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.78

varied ★★★★★ matched ★★★★★

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1a group of friends around a table chatting and laughing in a bustling bar with neon lights and shelves of bottles in the background

2a group of friends around a table chatting and laughing in a living room with a couch and bookshelves behind them

3a group of friends around a table chatting and laughing in a sunny garden with potted plants and flowers surrounding them

4a group of friends around a table chatting and laughing in a modern café with large windows and a counter in the background

Their questionnaire

study_round: 0

Useful to say what varies: ★★★★★

Slider behaved as expected: ★★★★☆

Enjoyed the task: ★★★★★

Preferred: Edit these

Uses image generators: Monthly

Wanted to vary but could not: varying only a selected image

Would do more: Yes

Participant 24 · Sep 25, 14:57

A cute elf girl in a bucket eating buggette

Prompt changed

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Participant 24 · Sep 25, 14:58

A cute elf girl sitting in a bucket eating buggette

Prompt changed

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis. The participant revised the prompt; it was: “A cute elf girl in a bucket eating buggette”.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Participant 24 · Sep 25, 14:59

A cute elf girl sitting inside a bucket eating buggette

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis. The participant revised the prompt; it was: “A cute elf girl sitting in a bucket eating buggette”.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Accepted

Age of a girl, buggete size

6 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.67

varied ★★★☆☆ matched ★★★★☆

“Age of a girl varied, but it was only on the two extreme end”

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A cute elder elf woman sitting inside a bucket eating buggette with a shrewd expression, wear a green pointed hat.

2A cute young teenager girl sitting inside a bucket eating buggette, with a playful look, wear a green elf outfit.

3A cute toddler girl sitting inside a bucket eating buggette, with a sweet expression, wear a green elf costume.

4A cute elf girl sitting inside a bucket eating big buggette sticks, with a surprised look, wear a green outfit.

Participant 24 · Sep 25, 15:01

A man with 10 watches on both hands

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1

number of watches, face of a man

7 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.78

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1add a young man's face to the image, looking at his watches

2add a bearded man's face in the background, smiling confidently

3add a close-up of an elderly man's face with glasses, looking thoughtful

4add six more watches on each wrist, totaling twelve watches per hand

Round 2 Accepted

number of watches, ethnicity of a man

7 words

new set · diversity 0.78

varied ★★★★★ matched ★★★☆☆

“It didn't follow the number of watches specified in the prompt”

round 2 image 1round 2 image 2round 2 image 3round 2 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A man with 10 watches on both hands. One watch per finger, plus wristwatches. Caucasian man, young, wearing a suit, smiling, colorful background, detailed watches.

2A man with 10 watches on both hands. Ten gold luxury watches covering every finger and wrist. African American man, beard, stylish hat, confident pose, city lights background.

3A man with 10 watches on both hands. Ten silver sport watches. Asian man, short hair, casual streetwear, holding coffee, vibrant neon sign background, dynamic action shot.

4A man with 10 watches on both hands. Ten colorful digital watches. Middle Eastern man, traditional thobe and ghutra, serious expression, desert sunset background, intricate watch details.

Participant 24 · Sep 25, 15:04

A slug with a headphone listening to music

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1

slug species

2 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.78

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A slug with a headphone listening to music, change the slug species to an African Garden Snail

2A slug with a headphone listening to music, change the slug species to a Japanese Land Snail

3A slug with a headphone listening to music, change the slug species to a colorful Indian Maus snail

4A slug with a headphone listening to music, change the slug species to a small garden slug with a yellow shell

Round 2

slug species

2 words

new set · diversity 0.78

round 2 image 1round 2 image 2round 2 image 3round 2 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A slug with a headphone listening to music. A cute, small garden slug with colorful striped shell, wearing wireless headphones, dancing to music, flowers background.

2A slug with a headphone listening to music. A large, dark grey marine slug with spikes, wearing vintage headphones, listening to jazz, underwater coral reef background.

3A slug with a headphone listening to music. A vibrant rainbow slug with glossy skin, oversized concert headphones, singing along, neon lights, party atmosphere.

4A slug with a headphone listening to music. A long, slender tree slug with green mucus, wearing futuristic cyberpunk headphones, sci-fi city background, listening to beats.

Round 3

slug species

2 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.11

round 3 image 1round 3 image 2round 3 image 3round 3 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1Change the slug species from a garden snail to an African Giant Land Snail.

2Change the slug species from a snail to a Sea Hare.

3Change the slug species from a snail to a Rainbow Slime Mole Snail.

4Change the slug species from a slum to a Zebra Snail.

Round 4 Accepted

slug species

2 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.33

varied ★★★★★ matched ★★★☆☆

“I specified slug but the images were of snails”

round 4 image 1round 4 image 2round 4 image 3round 4 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1Change the slug species to a garden snail with a brown-striped shell.

2Change the slug species to a colorful sea slug with blue and yellow patterns.

3Change the slug species to a jelly-like space slug with a cosmic, rainbow-painted shell.

4Change the slug species to a futuristic cyber-snail with a metallic green and black shell.

Participant 24 · Sep 25, 15:08

A racoon dog and a fox sitting in front of a shinto shrine

Accepted

Starting point

The prompt on its own, before any axis.

starting image 1starting image 2starting image 3starting image 4

Round 1 Accepted

racoon dog species, viewpoint

4 words

edited the previous set · diversity 0.67

varied ★★★★★ matched ★★★★☆

round 1 image 1round 1 image 2round 1 image 3round 1 image 4
Read the 4 prompts

1A raccoon dog and a fox sitting in front of a shinto shrine, add a capybara between them and change the viewpoint to a high-angle drone shot

2A nuttall's raccoon dog and a red fox sitting in front of a shinto shrine, change the viewpoint to a side profile view

3A eskimo raccoon dog and a fox sitting in front of a shinto shrine, change the viewpoint to a low-angle worm's-eye view

4A tanuki and a kit fox sitting in front of a shinto shrine, change the viewpoint to a close-up portrait from the front

Their questionnaire

study_round: 0

Useful to say what varies: ★★★★★

Slider behaved as expected: ★★★☆☆

Enjoyed the task: ★★★★★

Preferred: Edit these

Uses image generators: A few times

Wanted to vary but could not: Species of a slug

Would do more: Yes